Author Archives: Alex Carlile

Lord Carlile writes…Examining the evidence on assisted suicide

Simon Beard’s article on what he calls ‘the debate around legalising assisted dying’ is so replete with errors, half-truths and spin that it is difficult to know where to start with the correcting pen.

He refers to “the estimated 500 people who commit suicide each year due to a terminal or chronic illness”. The estimate he refers to was made in a report by Demos on the incidence of suicide among seriously ill people. This report does not state that 500 people commit suicide each year because they are terminally or chronically ill. It estimates that “approximately 10 per cent …

Posted in News | Tagged | 6 Comments



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarBill le Breton 20th Apr - 7:26pm
    Paul in T - I don't wish to labour the point nor am I saying that the Falkland's effect was a flash in the pan,...
  • User AvatarRoland 20th Apr - 7:12pm
    Thanks Simon for the correction. It would be interesting to know what the take up of the Stakeholder (personal) pension has been. As I suggest...
  • User Avatardaft ha'p'orth 20th Apr - 7:00pm
    @Ruaraidh "LDV below the line is just about as negative and dreary a place as it can be" It's a negative and dreary political universe,...
  • User AvatarRoland 20th Apr - 6:56pm
    Jenny Barnes - Thanks for the detailed response. I like your use of "Blue Peter" units to put some sense of scale on Ed Davey's...
  • User Avatarpaul barker 20th Apr - 5:12pm
    On the question of how we will do in The Euros. We know that we have been reduced to our core vote in Local Elections...
  • User AvatarRuaraidh 20th Apr - 4:37pm
    @ChrisB I don't think there'd be a great reduction in the number of people visiting the site if there were no comments, given that it's...