Opinion: Why we should back liberal Free Schools

Written by Christopher Leslie on 8th July 2008 – 8:19 pm

Tony Blair won his first election in 1997 on the back of his refrain, “education, education, education”, and in the run up to a likely 2010 general election the party leaders have already begun positioning themselves as offering radical proposals for education.

Nick Clegg and David Cameron have both voiced their support for seeing the introduction of Swedish-style ‘free schools’, where state funding, as is already standard, follows individual pupils; but in the case of free schools it also follows pupils into independent schools. Both Cameron and Clegg have made it clear that these schools would not involve academic selection (indicating a return to grammar schools) or be able to charge a top up fees (indicating the introduction of school vouchers). Both leaders are right to do so. Taking either or both those options would see an end to the meritocratic basis on which education is provided: state funding in education should go to all, regardless of ability, and shouldn’t be used to help the rich gain superior education.

On a similar theme, both leaders should also make it clear that they will not allow other barriers of entry to pupils, such as religion for example, and they shouldn’t become places for specific NGOs to promote their own agendas. Free schools need to be inclusive once pupils are in them.

Both Clegg and Cameron are right to support free schools: they offer a great chance to increase civil society, to provide better education in Britain, a greater level of plurality, and parents and children having increased choice and control in their education.

By declaring that the Conservatives will not allow firms to make a profit from the fee school system, however, Cameron is failing to fully utilise the opportunities free schools could offer, and which can only be accessed by allowing profit-making into the system. This might be the tokenistic suspicion of any institution making profit from state money; a refusal to take that idea to a public he fears won’t accept it; or that he’d rather see free schools be the sole domain of NGOs - which reveals a scary amount of paternalism. Whichever is the case, Clegg should not make the same mistake. Read more »


Posted in Op-eds | 71 Comments »

Opinion: Tories changing? Not at all

Written by Christopher Leslie on 13th March 2008 – 4:47 pm

I was lucky to grow up in a quiet little village. On one side the village is straddled by an air strip and Cranfield University. The Uni is postgraduate and as a result takes in a lot of foreign students - over a third of a 4,000 population. As a result in early years of school especially I met a lot of students from foreign cultures and many have grown up to be close friends. I also had the “pleasure” to grow up in a Conservative safe seat. Following corruption charges the Howard babe Nadine Dorries was moved in, who has rapidly become the rising female star of the Conservatives.

As a nurse, divorcé and council estate child I would expect more of Nadine than her recent comments on her blog regarding the creation of a Central Oxford Mosque:

Apparently, the minaret of a mosque, which will be built in Oxford, will stand taller than the dreamy spires… Whereas anyone walking by may not even notice the towering height, casting a shadow over a dreamy spire, to the Islamist it represents a triumphant call to arms.

By such logic my sister and mother who rings the local church bells are also terrorists - my mother is in fact a atheist who keeps fit by calling Christians to prayer.

Nadine should explain why rather than working with the Mosque to further understanding and integration she immediately jumps to a position of condemnation, accusing it of been a terrorist building “giving calls to arms” and by implication labelling all worshippers as terrorists. Comments like this can only increase the problems we face not solve them.

Such comments put doubt on how much I should expect from my MP. Tolerance and open mindedness are obviously not values she can live up to, instead falling immediately into intolerance and suspicion. To be frank, Islamaphobia isn’t an unreasonable accusation to throw her way. Such comments feed that constant voice in your head, that makes you really ask how deep the change in the Conservative party goes? It serves to only confirm that for at least some Tories the values which Cameron espouses is not a default position.

Christopher Leslie is a Mid Beds constituent and member of the Lib Dems.


Posted in Op-eds, Opposition watch | 19 Comments »
RSS

Liberal Democrat Voice is an independent, collaborative website run by Liberal Democrat activists, where any individual inside or outside the party can express their views. Views expressed on this website are those of the individuals who express them and may not reflect those of the party.