Ros Scott: can you spare 5 minutes for my online survey?

Written by Baroness Ros Scott on 7th July 2008 – 7:03 pm

People often ask me how I got involved in politics.

Putting down roots in Suffolk after many years of moving around, it was a revelation to me to see how a community really works. I became increasingly involved as a community activist and saw at first hand the great work done by my local Lib Dem councillor.

All political parties are now talking about localism, but for us is it part of our DNA. We need to ensure that we keep faith with our localist instincts and our natural inclination towards small and accountable decision-making.

I’ve always believed that our members and activists are the ones who define what this party is about. Community politics - sorting out your local play area; being a voice for those who wouldn’t otherwise be heard; even just ringing up your council to report a problem - these are examples of how Liberal Democrats are truly a part of their local area. Many people are either born Labour or Tory - but you have to choose to be a Liberal Democrat. That means we have already made a leap in thinking about what it is we really care about.

What applies to our localities also applies to our Party; we are best when our local parties thrive and the diversity which exists within them is celebrated.

Today I’m asking everyone who reads this to take five minutes to fill out my online survey at www.im4ros.com/survey. (Supporting my campaign is not compulsory of course!)

I’m primarily interested in getting a snapshot of some of the internal Party issues occupying you right now. For example, what should come first: electing MPs or Councillors? How can we win more votes: canvassing or media coverage?

So I would like your perspective - ideas and constructive criticisms - to be fed into this survey. Building on the survey work we did at the Liverpool Conference, I am going to run this on-line throughout July and August. Please send the link to as many people as you want –

www.im4ros.com/survey

Thanks so much!

* Baroness Ros Scott was appointed a life peer in 2000 and sits on the Liberal Democrat benches as Baroness Scott of Needham Market, having been a Liberal Democrat councillor in Suffolk from 1991.

NB: please note, this is not an official party survey.

Editor’s note: Liberal Democrat Voice will, as with all internal party elections, remain neutral in its editorial line, and seek to ensure balanced coverage of all candidates for the position of Party President. Supporters of the candidates - and the candidates themselves! - are encouraged to submit their views to Lib Dem Voice either as an article - find out how here - or comments; but the editor will seek to ensure fair representation on these pages for all candidates.


Posted in Party policy and consultation | 17 Comments »

Lords reform one year on

Written by Baroness Ros Scott on 7th March 2008 – 10:00 am

A year on from a House of Commons vote on Lords Reform, we asked Baroness Ros Scott about the prospect of the Commons getting its way.

When I was asked about going to the Lords, I was warned that I might not be there for long.  That was 8 years ago, and I’m not convinced that we’re much nearer to reforming the Lords than we were then.

There is a general consensus in the Commons that something needs to be done to democratise the second chamber, but a range of views about exactly what that should be.  Voting on the Cunningham report reflected that range, and resulted in a failure to gain a majority for any one of the six proposals on offer.   Last year’s vote at least progressed to a clear majority for a predominantly elected House, but legislation remains a distant prospect.

My views on the Lords have changed over time.   Until I got there, I was broadly in favour of an elected second chamber as a matter of principle.  I never felt moved to man the barricades on the issue, largely because the actual power of the Lords is so limited.   Working in the Lords, I have rather come to admire the way it works, the genuine expertise which resides there, and the fact that it usually avoids the more undesirable aspects of political point scoring.

But the “cash for peerages” allegations have hardened my views on the need for reform. I believe now that nothing short of a complete move to an elected Chamber can restore the credibility of the Lords.

And a credible second chamber is needed more now than ever before.  It is clear that the Commons is even further away from real change than the Lords.  An unrepresentative voting system, supine backbenchers and the power of government business managers means that the Commons is unable to hold the Executive to account.  It is not uncommon for Bills to arrive from the Commons with as much 40% of the content unscrutinised, because of the way the government whips manage the business.

Whilst that situation exists, a strong second chamber, with a public mandate, untainted by suspicion of corrupt appointment is a necessity.

And it is for that reason that I don’t think full reform will happen anytime soon.   I’m not sure that any government really wants a second chamber willing and able to flex its muscles.  Ensuring that the Lords remains partly appointed will be government’s way of clipping its wings.

My guess is that initial reform will remove the Bishops and the remaining hereditary peers.   A sort of voluntary retirement scheme will be offered, with a modest financial settlement based on past attendance.    This would clear some capacity for the election of a tranche of “senators” on a regional list basis, for a term of 12 (or 15) years non-renewable.

Five years later, the grim reaper will have  created space for a second elected list, and so on until we have a second chamber which around 80% elected.  The other 20% will be non political appointees.

The challenge for Liberal Democrat parliamentarians will be how much of a future programme for reform we can support.  Purists will urge rejection of everything short of a totally elected house, pragmatists will urge us to take any steps which move us closer to our ultimate goal.

Ros Scott speaks is a front-bench Lib Dem peer covering the  local government portfolio. Her website is here and her blog here.


Posted in News, Parliament | No Comments »

Opinion: Labour miss the point on communities

Written by Baroness Ros Scott on 13th January 2008 – 3:49 pm

I spent last week in Westminster, where in the Lords we spent Thursday afternoon debating the Government’s recently published “Action Plan for Community Empowerment”.

It’s hard to know which pair of words is the more depressing “Action Plan” or “Community Empowerment” Their Lordships certainly failed to be either empowered or active. Apart from the mover – my noble Friend Lord Greaves – and the front benches, there were 2 backbench speakers plus one Bishop making his Maiden speech on the subject. There were twice as many speakers for today’s other two debates, on China and on missile defence.

Read more »


Posted in Op-eds | 2 Comments »
RSS

Liberal Democrat Voice is an independent, collaborative website run by Liberal Democrat activists, where any individual inside or outside the party can express their views. Views expressed on this website are those of the individuals who express them and may not reflect those of the party.