George Bridges: my part in the Tories’ downfall. As a Lib Dem, I approve this message

There’s a fascinating article today in the Telegraph by George Bridges: The Tories have gone astray – and I helped. Who’s George Bridges, you ask? Here’s his summary of his political career to date:

First a researcher for the Conservative Party machine, then a tour of duty in the bunker of No 10 for the last three Major years, followed by a few years advising Michael Howard and David Cameron.

It’s a hefty 1,000-word ‘Consevatism: my part in its downfall’ mea culpa, and it’s fascinating in two ways.

First, for its call to arms for Conservatives to ignore the polling and simply stand up for what they believe in. George Bridges freely admits, though not in quite these words, that the whole Cameron modernising project was a sham, that the party put its desperation for votes ahead of its deeply held convictions.

Fair enough, you might say. After all, many Lib Dems were pointing out how inauthentic the Cameron Project was in real-time, back when the media hack-pack was in thrall to his shiny newness.

But the second reason the article is fascinating is for the three issues George Bridges highlights as the key ones where the Tory party made the wrong call for fear of frightening the voters:

1) The Tory promise to ‘match Labour’s commitment to spend more and more on public services’. This Cameron/Osborne pledge was designed to neutralise fears the Tories would slash public spending. (It mirrored the Blair/Brown promise in ’97 to stick to Tory tax-and-spend plans.) Here George Bridges has a point, I think. Labour was right to pump money back into our public services after years of neglect; but it wasn’t all spent effectively; and there was an over-correction which meant the UK ran a too-large deficit in the belief the good times would keep on rolling. The Tories and Lib Dems (notwithstanding Vince’s warnings about private debt bubbles) were both complicit in allowing that situation to continue unchallenged.

2) ‘For years, politicians dared not admit that exam standards were being devalued by grade inflation.’ Assertion isn’t evidence. I’ve made the same glib comments myself in the past, been challenged on it, and looked at the evidence — there is some, but it’s limited and very hard to disentangle from a multitude of other explanations, including improvements in teaching and/or teachers ‘teaching to the test’ and/or pupils getting smarter.

3) ‘Immigration. Fear of being labelled a racist quashed public debate during the Blair years.’ Well, it was either going to be Europe or immigration: no Tory list of Evil Policies is complete without these two horsemen of the apocalypse galloping forth. Perhaps it was fear of the R-label which self-censored Tories. I had hoped it was recognition that the free movement of labour drives better economic growth, that the party had at last recognised that supply-side economics includes freeing employers to hire people with the skills required to do the jobs they want to create. But I was clearly naive: the traditional Tory argument remains, immovable: there are just too many foreign-types in the UK.

So there we have it: George Bridges’ clarion call for a return to authentic Conservative values that’s being applauded by right-wing commentators this morning. Which is fine: absolutely, people should stick up for what they believe, no matter how evidence-free or irrational. George Bridges, I suspect, speaks for many and perhaps most Tories. Ironically, he is, once again, going with the flow of his party, which is drifting irresistibly to the right.

That’s causing tensions within the Coalition (just ask Ed Davey) yet it also makes the Lib Dem task that much easier. Eighteen months ago Nick Clegg worried in a hot-mic moment that he and David Cameron ‘won’t find anything to bloody disagree on in the bloody TV debates!’ There’s no danger now.

The Tories are beating a hasty exit away from the mainstream of British politics, back to their comfort zone of Little Englander nimbyism. The tide of Conservative modernism has gone out, leaving their few, sensible pragmatists beached. That’s a shame for them, but it’s an opportunity for the Lib Dems.

* Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

8 Comments

  • Foregone Conclusion 21st Nov '12 - 9:25am

    ‘Immigration. Fear of being labelled a racist quashed public debate during the Blair years.’

    Except for most of the newspapers in this country running overwhelmingly negative stories on it every. single. day.

    And the numerous promises (many of them ‘successful’) from Labour and the Tories to crack down on ‘bogus asylum seekers’, ‘sponging’ migrants, or whoever the devil of the week might happen to be.

    And, of course, the fact that the Tories ran largely on an anti-immigration platform for two successive elections (clue: it didn’t go that well!)

    Of course, the ultimate example of the PC brigade’s successful attempt to shut down free debate on the issue is the fact that immigration came up as an issue in only three out of three leaders’ debates in 2010.

  • 2) ‘For years, politicians dared not admit that exam standards were being devalued by grade inflation.’ Assertion isn’t evidence.

    You have linked to evidence that this assertion is perfectly true, and not to any evidence that it is untrue.

  • Actually we are the 52nd most densely populated country in the world, the Netherlands are24th and Belgium is 35th and Germany just behind us at 56th. It is quite possible to drive through swathes of the UK that are almost empty (come up to North Yorshire for example). Our problem is quite simply that the area around London and the South East is grossly overcrowded, how are we going to solve that?

  • Fomer Lib supporter 21st Nov '12 - 4:25pm

    “First, for its call to arms for Conservatives to ignore the polling and simply stand up for what they believe in. George Bridges freely admits, though not in quite these words, that the whole Cameron modernising project was a sham, that the party put its desperation for votes ahead of its deeply held convictions.”

    Seems to me exactly what your party has done!

  • Dave G Fawcett 22nd Nov '12 - 10:38am

    ‘For years, politicians dared not admit that exam standards were being devalued by grade inflation.’

    I can only comment that I did a degree course back in the 1970,’s (failed) and I’m doing another one now – at the Open University – to while away the days of my declining years. This second time round it’s a piece of p***. The pass mark for assignments is only 40% for goodness sake. On personal experience alone standards have fallen over the last couple of generations!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarDavid Pearce 5th Dec - 8:09am
    If libs are the only party campaigning for Remain, and UkIP are fighting to take leave votes, then this becomes a three way marginal seat....
  • User AvatarAlistair 5th Dec - 7:55am
    The problem with this analysis is that if financial self interest is ruled out as a primary motive, the alternative motives for voting against the...
  • User AvatarMark Goodrich 5th Dec - 5:12am
    Just as a footnote, I probably voted against my economic interests as well. I get paid in dollars which has meant a major and very...
  • User AvatarRoland 5th Dec - 2:18am
    "There is a window of opportunity available to any party which has been the most pro remain at the point Brexit is shown to be...
  • User AvatarEddie Sammon 5th Dec - 12:36am
    I've made my fair share of complaints at the time and after one time receiving a response I felt was unsatisfactory I began to support...
  • User AvatarLorenzo Cherin 5th Dec - 12:21am
    The odd thing to me is why so many in our party have such slavish loyalty to institutions, a very statist left or conservative right...