George Lyon MEP writes: Lib Dem MEPs will resist secret EU vote

Last week the European Council agreed a new European budget that will, for the first time, see a cut in the amount of money that the EU spends.

Liberal Democrats at Westminster and in the European Parliament have made clear that the EU needs to live within its means. We are in favour of a sensible and realistic deal that reflects the tough economic times that ordinary people are facing. Some MEPs see things differently and oppose the idea of a degree of fiscal restraint in Europe.

People who oppose the cuts in the EU budget that have been put forward are perfectly entitled to their views. To be clear, there are legitimate debates to be had over the terms of the deal that was announced last week. We need, for example, to ensure that the money we are spending is delivering for the UK, helping us to create the stronger economy and fairer society that we all want to see. We also need to look at how we can give the European Parliament the flexibility to manage a smaller budget more effectively.

What is wholly illegitimate is the idea that these debates – and subsequent votes in the European Parliament – should be conducted in secret. Voting on the next EU budget is one of the most important decisions MEPs will take  in this mandate.  Scrutinising the terms of the deal that has been put forward is a key part of our work. It is vital that we are open and transparent in our decision making.

Politics is all about debate. The European Parliament accommodates MEPs who hold a diverse range of opinions on a wide range of issues. What is critical is that MEPs have the courage of their convictions. As elected representatives we have to take responsibility and account for the decisions we are taking and the votes we are casting.

It has been reported that that MEPs of the European Peoples Party, which is one of the largest centre-right groupings in Brussels, could seek to force a secret ballot using procedural rules. This is an idea that Martin Schulz, the socialist President of the EU Parliament, has also backed.

As the Prime Minister said in the House of Commons on Monday, the idea of a secret ballot is an extraordinary concept. Transparency is something that is absolutely central to our democracy. It is absolutely wrong that MEPs who are elected to represent the views of their constituents should seek to hide their votes in the manner that is being advocated by some in Brussels.

Since this first came to light, Liberal Democrat MEPs have made our views clear. We do not support a secret vote and will be working hard to persuade others that this approach is fundamentally wrong headed. For a secret vote to go ahead, 151 MEPs would need to sign up. No Liberal Democrat MEPs will be in that number and we will resist this anti-democratic measure.

* George Lyon is Liberal Democrat MEP for Scotland and Vice President of the European Budget Committee.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Europe / International and Op-eds.
Advert

13 Comments

  • Simon McGrath 13th Feb '13 - 12:01pm

    Excellent. Can you tell us the position of ALDE ?

  • “… and we will resist this anti-democratic measure.”
    A first and very welcome admission from a Lib Dem, that the EU is inherently anti-democratic at its core.

  • @Dave Page
    Why would a supposed democratic institution, have in its structure, the ability to even consider, hiding its vote from public gaze?
    Answer : Because the EU wants the facility to hide its accountability, and therefore its deficit of democracy. Not only are secret EU votes wrong, it’s abhorrent to even have it as an option. But then it is par for the course, given that the EU is an abhorrent structure.

  • @Anthony :
    Why would an MP or MEP want to hide from their electorate, what they have vote for ?
    And how is an average voter to decide if a refreshing a candidates mandate, (MP or MEP), is appropriate, if you don’t know how they have voted on a particular issue?

  • Antony – there is a difference between private session and private votes. I think that Council votes are a matter of public record (albeit not all recorded) even when they are discussing the matter in closed proceedings.

    The only time I can recall a secret Parliamentary vote was the most recent speaker election.

  • John D – so how many votes, representing what proportion of the total, have been conducted secretly?

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarThe Professor 28th Aug - 5:32pm
    @Sue Sutherland I have not looked it up but I recall that if circa 2,000 voters had switched from Tory to the runner-up party in...
  • User AvatarMatthew Huntbach 28th Aug - 5:30pm
    Adam Casey If you start from the assumption “a large fraction of this country are evil people who want to do evil things” then you’re...
  • User AvatarPaul Walter 28th Aug - 4:56pm
    But Stuart. You are saying that the Labour party - who have spent 100+ years saying that the Tories are evil - would tell the...
  • User AvatarGlenn 28th Aug - 4:56pm
    If this is really about freedom, then could you not equally argue that as it is not enforced by religious codes then overtly religious clothing...
  • User AvatarDavid Evans 28th Aug - 4:51pm
    Barry, I'm not sure what you are getting at with your "I am astonished the pollsters can be so accurate after the election when they...
  • User AvatarErnest 28th Aug - 4:27pm
    I hope is that if Scotland does get its independence, that my own country of Wales follows. Thought of 'English votes for English laws' in...