LibLink: Willie Rennie – after the referendum

Willie Rennie - Some rights reserved by Liberal DemocratsIn The Scotsman, Willie Rennie asks some pertinent questions about what might happen after the Scottish referendum:

The Electoral Commission surprised us all on Wednesday when it went beyond spending limits and the wording of the question to press for clarity on the process after either result in the referendum. It did not ask us to negotiate a solution on the substance of our conflicting cases as pre-negotiations are impossible.

Yet, on reflection, I believe this will ­assist those who share my view that Scotland should remain in the UK.

Although the Nationalists say negotiations could be wrapped up in 16 months you only have to consider what would need to be agreed to realise it may take much longer. To start with there is Scotland’s place in the UN, EU and Nato, never mind the UK’s 15,000 international treaties. When would the deadline be for the redrafting of centuries worth of legislation and regulations? What would ­happen if Scots didn’t like the deal secured by the Nationalists?

Yu can read the full article here.

* Paul Walter is a Liberal Democrat activist in Newbury and West Berkshire. He is part of the Liberal Democrat Voice team and blogs at Liberal Burblings.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in LibLink.
Bookmark the web address for this page or use the short url http://ldv.org.uk/33026 for Twitter and emails.
Advert

3 Comments

  • I thought that precedent esablishes that the successor states inherit the treaties and obligations of the previous state. Surely this has to be the case, otherwise there would be a spate of succeeding states as a device to shrug off national debts. Would Crete become debt free simply by splitting from Greece? – I do not think so.

    I am unclear why devo max or devo plus is not on the table. Surely this is the most popular option, yet it is not available. It seems to me that every ‘Yes’ vote strengthens this choice whilst a ‘No’ vote reinforces the status quo. I see a parallel here with the AV vote, which in effect became a reaffirmation of FPTP.

    A ‘Yes’ vote opens up negotiations and establishes a direction of travel (with possibly a variable timetable for arrival).

  • Steve Comer 4th Feb '13 - 11:50pm

    Surely we have many precedents for states breaking away from countries don’t we?
    Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Slovakia etc. were all re-established in the early 1990s, what about the ‘thousands of treaties’ they would have been part of? I don’t remember a crisis of legislative re-drafting in these countries.
    Sorry but the ‘better together’ campaign needs to do more than just silly scaremongering if its going to win a referendum.
    There is actually a powerful argument on subsidiarity grounds for Scottish independence, not in the old narrow nationalist sense, but in a desire that Scotland’s future lies as a state ruling itself within the context of the European Union.
    Liberal supported Home Rule for Scotland and Ireland 100 years ago, why have we become little unionists now?

  • Steve, I agree completely and have commented on other threads to the effect that the apparent Lig Dem position does not seem to add up.

    On this forum there has been little in the way of response. Perhaps it is a lack of interest, a lack of policy or simply tacit dismissal of anything other than the status quo. It is depressing to see Lib Dems joining in with scare mongering.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarNick Collins 6th Mar - 1:58pm
    @ Matthew Huntbach., please do not take my comment personally; it was not addressed specifically at you Although you comment on this site more frequently...
  • User AvatarJohnTilley 6th Mar - 1:57pm
    "...devolving power from national politicians to local politicians is often important, but by itself it amounts to municipal socialism, not liberalism. " What a bizarre...
  • User AvatarAlex Macfie 6th Mar - 1:46pm
    I think we need to abolish the word "multiculturalism". It's one of those words that means whatever its user wants it to mean.
  • User AvatarSue S 6th Mar - 1:25pm
    To Nigel Jones and all those who want to go out and canvass please do so and tell people what the Lib Dems have achieved...
  • User AvatarManfarang 6th Mar - 1:15pm
    Paul Walter "Melting pot" to "Mosaic" will give you a better understanding of America. It has experienced its greatest wave of immigration in the last...
  • User AvatarDaniel Carr 6th Mar - 1:06pm
    I have two: On Liberty - JS Mill: already mentioned, but such a powerful argument for letting people live as they choose even if you...