Opinion: We shouldn’t be shy about political failure over the economy

Last week was, behind the scenes, an important one for the future of UK economic reforms. Four reports were published which were, one might say, bang on for the new mantra of ‘re-balancing the economy’.

The first was Lord Heseltine’s report on the role and methods of the UK government in ‘achieving’ economic growth. The other three were reviews conducted via the Bank of England in response to criticisms of its handling of the financial crisis – specifically its bailouts, and its evident surprise in 2007 that much of the UK banking system would collapse without such bailouts.

The Heseltine report was somewhat narrow in ‘scope and remedy’ in that it focused on the UK’s low productivity. It defined the obstacles to growth in terms of how the state uses its economic development money and expertise – specifically that business support and infrastructure development cooperation were both badly run and too centralised. The solutions proposed included a consolidation and then decentralisation of business support budgets and private infrastructure investment facilitation activities. Heseltine also proposed one of my old calls – for a Cabinet Committee on economic growth.

The implied but obvious point of this report is that the government, two and a half years into its life, has no robust definition of ‘the growth problem’ and no robust strategy.

The three reports from the Bank of England very politely conclude that its very governance systems were flawed, particularly that they were too hierarchical and deferential. The Tory MP Andrew Tyrie, Chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, has been a vocal critic of the Bank of England’s governance and that of the Financial Services Authority. He has criticised these three reports, for being too polite, but more importantly for being too weak. He has argued that a more comprehensive and independent report was needed on how on earth the well-funded and detailed system of bank regulation by the Bank of England and the FSA, with extensive bank-by-bank monitoring, could have been ‘surprised’ by the UK banking system being in a bankrupt state!  Tyrie’s implied but obvious point is that the UK still has no robust definition of the banking problem, and no robust set of remedies beyond ‘Chinese Walls’ between retail and investment banking, still unimplemented.

Both sets of issues represent a failure of the ‘political class’ to get to grips with institutional failure. Transforming the support role of the British state in non-financial sectors so that it up there with Japan, Germany and Scandanavian countries, is a major but necessary task yet to be embarked on.

I recall a small meeting I attended at the Bank of England some years ago at which Alan Greenspan was present. Bank of England officials quietly explained that they were in favour of a more monopolistic UK banking sector and generally against new market entrants and the kind of dynamic banking sector found in successful economies.  The reason given was that it makes for a strong and soundly resourced sector. Well, it didn’t work did it ? As ever, monopolistic sectors end in tears. The results are evident in Britain’s communities  where Heseltine wants to devolve powers. The wonderful case of The Bank of Dave shows clearly how this strategy in favour of a restricted sector is still being applied, to the clear detriment of UK growth.

So can the Coalition finally get to grips with these two challenges? They will require extraordinary effort. Perhaps the answer would be to ensure that an outsider is made Governor of the Bank of England. My suggestion would be Sharon Bowles MEP. Perhaps Heseltine should get his Growth Cabinet Committee, but with Vince Cable as Chair. But somehow the political class must overcome the entrenched obstacles.

* Paul Reynolds works with multilateral organisations as an independent adviser on international relations, economics, and senior governance.

Read more by .
This entry was posted in News.

One Comment

  • Liberal Eye 8th Nov '12 - 5:50pm

    “Transforming the support role of the British state in non-financial sectors so that it up there with Japan, Germany and Scandanavian countries, is a major but necessary task yet to be embarked on.”

    On this and other points – absolutely! I don’t get any sense that the political establishment has even identified where the game is being staged let alone getting into it. All we get are reheated versions of ‘solutions’ that have failed before. How do we advance from this position?

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarCaron Lindsay 27th Aug - 10:41am
    Although, Hireton, there is a main opposition party whose leader gets the lion's share of questions at FMQs.
  • User AvatarPeter Parsons 27th Aug - 10:41am
    The airline comparison has flaw. Airplanes only have slots at takeoff and landing. Trains have slots for the whole of a journey due to being...
  • User AvatarPeter Parsons 27th Aug - 10:41am
    @Graham Evans "“If the train I planned to catch is delayed or cancelled I simply want to be able get on the next one on...
  • User AvatarHireton 27th Aug - 10:36am
    @lorenzo cherin There is no 'official opposition' in Scotland, that is a quaint tradition of Westminster.
  • User AvatarTony Dawson 27th Aug - 10:16am
    What i would do if I were Mayor of Nice would be to get a group of nice women in headscarfs to demonstrate/distribute leaflets with...
  • User AvatarTony Dawson 27th Aug - 10:11am
    I feel that fat guys on all Europe's beaches (and those in the UK, Donald!) in over-tight Speedos should all be forced to wear burkinis...