Tag Archives: boundary commission

Opinion: Boundary nonsense

Boundary - Some rights reserved by ank0kuOn the face of it, the boundary change proposals were about cutting costs by having less MPs and strengthening democracy by having each MP represent roughly identical numbers of voters. Neither of these claims bear close scrutiny.

Our democracy is not a simple thing – it struggles its way through the conflicting needs of the nation and the individual. It is unrealistic to base our representation on population statistics alone. It’s true that there are a few Parliamentary seats with fairly sparsely populated

Posted in Op-eds | 9 Comments



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarLiberal Neil 20th Aug - 5:20pm
    Most of the points put forward by Denis in the article and in the comment by John Barrett are perfectly reasonable. If people currently on...
  • User AvatarDav 20th Aug - 4:42pm
    the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is a good expression of what mid-20th century liberals believed to be universal rights and values And 'British values'...
  • User AvatarEddie Sammon 20th Aug - 4:31pm
    Thanks Tony Hill, as you say, I think a feeling of lack of power and injustice is something to do with it and we should...
  • User AvatarIain 20th Aug - 4:30pm
    There is a strange assumption in the 'Yes' camp that rUK will want have some interest in promoting the interests of Scotland, in some cases...
  • User AvatarIan MacFadyen 20th Aug - 4:30pm
    It is silly to condemn the Better Together campaign for being negative. It exists to oppose a bad idea and ensure that it is voted...
  • User AvatarJohn Barrett 20th Aug - 4:22pm
    Moving away from the Islamic State debate to the Scottish State. With Federalism not an option in the September 18th referendum and Westminster unlikely to...