The Big Society: the answer’s in the book

One of the curios of some library campaigners extolling the virtues of books whilst also mocking the Big Society for supposedly being incomprehensible or non-existent is that there is a short, clear and well-written book which lays out just what it is. Conservative MP Jesse Norman’s book, The Big Society, is certainly not uncontroversial, but it makes a sufficiently strong and clear case to have received favourable comments from across the political spectrum on its publication last autumn, including from Labour MP Jon Cruddas.

At times the book seems to have two, almost contradictory, purposes – to persuade traditional Conservatives that the Big Society is a Conservative idea they should be comfortable with, but also to persuade non-Conservatives that the Big Society is an idea that reaches out beyond the bounds of traditional Conservative ideology and so should also appeal to them. As a result, The Big Society ends up skating close to trying to be all things to all people. All people, that is, except for Fabians who are routinely criticised throughout the book for their historic love of centralisation and top-down control.

The other main weakness of Jesse Norman’s book is the lack of consideration of where we start from. Jesse Norman emphasises the benefits of giving people the opportunities to make their own choices – both because it makes for a more free society and because, he argues, giving people more control over their job and their organisation makes for more efficient (public) services and a more successful economy. However, we do not all start from an equal place, and those questions of inherited wealth, privilege and opportunity get little attention from him.

The Big Society by Jesse Norman - book coverIn Norman’s wide-ranging book (which is worth the read simply for the overview it gives of many political and economic debates, whether or not you agree with his conclusions), he repeatedly stresses two themes that he says both free marketers and Fabians have neglected – that humans are sociable beings and that institutions matters. In other words, neither the free market emphasis on the interactions of fully autonomous individuals nor the Fabian-style preference for top down control fully appreciate the way humans interact with each other, relying on and prospering from the existence of a large range of intermediary institutions.

To a Liberal Democrat ear, some of this sounds very similar to community politics (and much of the criticism of traditional economics and the failings of markets, alongside calls for restrain on excessive corporate pay, will sound familiar to more left-wing ears too).

Norman’s own conclusions are that the central state should be smaller, but that it should not simply be rolled back and all left to individuals. Instead, there needs to be a growing and healthy mix of other institutions, whether it is mutuals that provide public services, local groups that give a voice to community concerns or simply organisations that bring people together to enjoy shared interests. At the same time, rather than trying to target outcomes – an approach Jesse Norman says ends up in failure under New Labour with ever-more draconian central control and target setting – government should target capabilities, giving people power and skills and then letting them get on with whatever they wish. There is an echo there of Nick Clegg’s own preference for talking of social mobility rather than about outcomes.

But despite the echoes of views held by those in other parties, this is clearly a book from a Conservative MP laying out a prescription for a Conservative Party. Nonetheless, it is well worth a read by a wider audience.

You can buy The Big Society by Jesse Norman from Amazon here.

Read more by or more about , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in Books and Op-eds.
Advert

2 Comments

  • Tony Greaves 1st May '11 - 11:35pm

    It is worth reading in order to realise what garbage it all is! (I have just done so as part of my continuing enquiry into just what the Big Society is or is not – now I am about to start on Red Tory by Philip Blond, a man who did not impress me when I met him at the Liverpool conference).

    “short, clear and well-written book “? Hm. It’s short. Clear? I thought “clear as mud”. Lots of cod philosophy and a lot of discursive Tory discussion and rebuttals of attacks on the Big Society, What it is not is a clear explanation of what the BS actually is. (Except that it is the same as Compassionate Conservatism – as defined by Norman).

    Community politics it certainly is not. However I kept asking myself what my reaction to it would be if I was a mainstream Tory – and I think the answer is “utterly bewildered”. If Cameron thinks this stuff is what will define his premiership, it’s going to be a Big Flop. That may be a consolation.

    Tony Greaves

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarCaracatus 26th Jul - 8:43pm
    A largely dull and irrelevant conference agenda that will pass by the attendees and the public with no impact. It is stuck in the 1970's....
  • User AvatarLittle Jackie Paper 26th Jul - 8:41pm
    Mr Holloway - As a matter of interest, how did you vote in the referendum? http://www.libdemvoice.org/opinion-the-commonwealth-and-the-eu-46507.html
  • User AvatarCaracatus 26th Jul - 8:37pm
    @ rightsaidfredfan - we that might be because your opinion isn't as valid, for example, the poster about the "Lets give out NHS the £350m...
  • User Avatarpaul barker 26th Jul - 8:07pm
    More United seems like a brilliant idea to me & very obviously designed not to be a Proto-Party or a new version of The SDP/Liberal...
  • User AvatarMick Taylor 26th Jul - 8:03pm
    Lets be absolutely clear. No deal with the EU will be as good as the one we have now. If the government want to put...
  • User AvatarHywel 26th Jul - 7:58pm
    "To be honest its no different to the the Political Action Committees they have in the states the fund candidates that support the views of...
Tue 26th Jul 2016
Thu 28th Jul 2016
Sat 30th Jul 2016
Mon 1st Aug 2016
Wed 3rd Aug 2016
Sat 6th Aug 2016
Wed 10th Aug 2016
Fri 12th Aug 2016
19:00
Thu 18th Aug 2016
Sun 21st Aug 2016