The weekend debate: Would Mitt Romney make a better President than Barack Obama?

Here’s your starter for ten in our weekend slot where we throw up an idea or thought for debate…

Over the last three years Obama has had to concede much of his programme to Republicans in Congress. His healthcare reforms had to be significantly watered down even before Republicans won back the House of Representatives in 2010. And the reforms themselves have since acted as a lightning rod for criticism of the President.

Obama is struggling to get the economy going again amid continued turbulence in the global economy and unemployment is staying stubbornly high despite the massive £800 billion stimulus package. Even now he is under fire from both left and right for not being able to secure a deal on the deficit.

With such a difficult background for the current president, is Mitt Romney right to believe he could do a better job?

Would his experience as a businessman and a successful state governor create the change that the country needs?

And would a Republican president be able to better bridge the gap between Tea Party Republicans and moderate Democrats in Congress?

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in LDVUSA and Op-eds.
Bookmark the web address for this page or use the short url for Twitter and emails.


  • Liberal Neil 29th Oct '11 - 10:08am


  • Adam Corlett 29th Oct '11 - 10:25am


    I’m not sure which scares me more: the prospect of another 2-4 years of a divided Congress and White House where not even the most basic legislation can be passed, or the idea of the Republicans controlling all three bodies.

  • How can anyone tell? It’s difficult to hear what Romney is sayi above the sound of his flip flops.

    From a US point of view, From a foreign policy angle, Obama has it sewn up. Romney can hardly better him.

    On economic affairs, Romney is likely to be pretty damaged by Perry’s attacks. And then we’ll hear all about Romney’s mass lay-offs from his Bain days and possibly benefitting from bail outs. Look back at Teddy Kennedy’s campaign against Romney in 1994 to get a sense of what is to come.

    But yes, from a liberal point of view, you’d have to be insane to believe Romney would be better than Obama.

  • Absolutely not. The only reason why the President has not been able to move his agenda forward is because of a massive effort by the Republicans to, in every way, completely de-legitimise every aspect of his Presidency.

    The President sends in troops to help stop the violet Lord’s Resistance Army? They smear him as an evil Islamist out to destroy Christians.

    Some Republican attacks Rick Perry for his Uni marks? Then everyone goes after the President claiming that the only reason he got into the best US law school (Harvard) was because he was black.

    It’s insanity. And the question is not even worth asking.

  • I really don’t mind the republicans getting in.

    They are totally anti-science.. and if science collapses in the US it will move elsewhere… e.g. here. Although I suspect China and India will probably benefit more than Europe. Their economic and social policies (oh wait.. they just want to get rid of all of them) are going to turn the US into a 2nd or 3rd world country. Either that or there will be another civil war.

    The only thing that worries me with the republicans getting is having a theocracy with nuclear weapons.

  • Brenda Lana Smith R. af D. 30th Oct '11 - 11:01am

    Obama for a second term—period!

  • No,no, a thousand times no.

    We all know that the vast majority of Obama’s problems (not all – he is a human being) are caused by the strength of the Republicans in Congress. Giving them the presidency as well does not seem to be the optimal solution!
    However it is the US electorate who will decide and they may do just that – with Romney or even worse.

    “The real problem with America is the American electorate” – discuss!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarLittle Jackie Paper 1st Sep - 8:54pm
    tonyhill - Agree about Orwell's breadth. He was one of the best journalists of the time. He was a sharp, astute essayist. And, sadly, a...
  • User Avatarcrewegwyn 1st Sep - 8:48pm
    In his first comment Joe Otten seems to imply that Lib Dems who favour exit from the EU should not be on LDV. Is that...
  • User AvatarJoeBourke 1st Sep - 8:46pm
    In 'Looking back on the Spanish Civil War' Orwell wrote "All that the working man demands is what ... others would consider the indispensable minimum...
  • User Avatartonyhill 1st Sep - 8:23pm
    Discussing Orwell on a blog is probably not the best of mediums because his writing was so wide-ranging and nuanced, but 'the genuinely popular culture...
  • User AvatarDavidW 1st Sep - 8:18pm
    @John Tilley: "“You’d be pushed to find any policy all 8 MPs agree on which could be described as radical” This is indeed true, because...
  • User AvatarIan Sanderson (RM3) 1st Sep - 8:17pm
    On Sunday evening, I attended, accompanying my wife, an event in Malmo City Hall. (Sweden). It was an event for squash players from all over...