On the subject of immigration, Ed Miliband was in apologetic mood this week. And not before time.
Labour has a lot to apologise for on immigration – not just the dog whistle ‘British Jobs for British Workers’ rhetoric and an attitude to the views of ordinary people that resulted in Gordon Brown’s ‘bigoted woman’ slur.
Miliband could apologise for not reintroducing the exit checks abolished by the Tories and allowing our border controls to descend into farce.
He could apologise for wildly underestimating the number of migrants from Eastern Europe when new countries joined the EU.
But if there is one thing Labour really should be sorry for it is the disgrace of child detention for immigration purposes.
Under Labour, thousands of children and young people were locked up, often for months on end, for the mistakes of their parents.
These innocent children were often left physically and emotionally scarred by their experience in conditions that have no place in a modern, civilised country.
And this was happening on an industrial scale. In Labour’s last five years in office 7,075 children were detained – four children a day.
This national tragedy was something that the Liberal Democrats campaigned against, fought to include in the Coalition Agreement, and delivered in our first year in office.
The Liberal Democrats have taken a lot of knocks since joining the Coalition but the ending of child detention is one of those decisions that remind us why it is worth having Liberals in government for the first time in generations.
As my fellow Liberal Democrat Alex Cole-Hamilton said after losing a close election in Edinburgh last year, if losing was part payment for the ending child detention then “I accept it, with all my heart.”
To the critics who claim that the child detention system has been replaced and not ended, this could not be further from the truth.
The current practices for children awaiting deportation cannot be – and should not be – in any way compared to the shameful past. Children are no longer held for weeks on end as they were under Labour.
Only on the rare occasions when a family was denied entry at the border and there was no immediate return flight, have they been held in pre-departure accommodation until the next available flight, usually within 24 to 48 hours.
And the conditions they are held in simply bear no resemblance to those they replaced – prison-like centres in places like Yarl’s Wood replaced by family-friendly centres run with support from groups like Barnardos.
Getting to grips with our farcical immigration system while treating children with decency and humanity is not easy, but the Coalition is succeeding where Labour failed.
Labour has much to apologise for on immigration. It should start with child detention.
* Tom Brake is Liberal Democrat MP for Carshalton and Wallington, and Deputy Leader of the House of Commons
Follow @LibDemVoice on Twitter
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
The Sun story about Chris Huhne that was a total invention (and which the other papers happily copied)
Liberal Democrat MPs to be given free vote on all aspects of Same Sex Marriage Bill
Opinion: Why Lib Dems should support the Referendum on the EU – and let’s have it before 2015
Where Ukip won (or almost won) on 2nd May 2013
Ukip surge to 18% in latest ICM poll: Lib Dems at 11%
Opinion: Lib Dem MPs: Vote for equality, human rights and love today
Stephen Gilbert MP writes… Equal marriage is now a litmus test for Cameron
When Mr Farage came to Edinburgh – the ugly side of politics
Lord Roger Roberts writes: Don’t try to win votes by coming down hard on migrants
"Oh hey there you mad swivel eyed loons... Want to Canvass for us in the Euros?"
rate payers multi million losses down to poor governance under Sefton Lab new info
Equal Marriage is a baby step towards a Utopian society.
The real Lib Dem position on an EU referendum
Anti equal marriage campaigners set up hate camp outside Parliament
Maghull Homes - Now Parkhaven Trust - 125 years of social care in Maghull
Alright, let's make this official
Norman Lamb: Doh!
Time to address the shortage of Welsh nurses
Quote of the Day - Sean Thomas on how David Cameron will win the next general election
Richard Marbrow
Stuart Mitchell
GF
Jon Danzig
johnmc
8 Comments
So the Coalition has minimised child detention rather than ended it.
Duncan’s right – best to be honest about the wording else it’ll come back to bite us.
I’m broadly liberal, but if there’s one thing I fully respect about Thathcher, it was the Primary Purpose Rule. New Labour, namely Jack Straw, should apologise for abolishing it. It was one of the most effective measures to counter bogus marriages from places like Pakistan.
While Labour does has a lot to apologise for on immigration, criticising it for both “the dog whistle ‘British Jobs for British Workers’ rhetoric” and for an “attitude to the views of ordinary people that resulted in Gordon Brown’s ‘bigoted woman’ slur” seems a bit contradictory.
On child detention, however, I wasn’t even aware of that issue, to be honest. Good on you for ending it, and Labour should address it.
Surprising then to read that the Independent Monitoring Board report published last month stated that children are being held, including overnight, in “degrading and disgraceful” conditions at Heathrow Airport by the UK Border Agency (UKBA)”. The report pointed out that, in 2011, up to 3,000 people were held for more than 12 hours, requiring many – including children – to spend the night there rather than at immigration removal centres. Inspectors found that “the rooms where children were held had no natural light, no access to the open air, and no sleeping arrangements.”
“Miliband could apologise for not reintroducing the exit checks abolished by the Tories and allowing our border controls to descend into farce.”
The point of ‘exit checks’ is what exactly? Unless you subscribe to the ridiculous idea that the government should be able to supply an exact figure for the number of people in the country at any time of the day or night (a product of the warped mind of Damian Green), or the equally pointless and downright offensive idea, which seems to be assumed in our border system, that we need permission from the state to leave the country (welcome to east Germany), then there is no reason whatsoever for exit checks.
Another stupid waste of money to keep racists happy.
An excellent posting, and a story about ending children being locked in detention centres before removal after living in this country, that needs to be told again and again.
It is shameful that our supposedly civilised country behaved in such a barbaric way. there are still many issues to tackle, including the recently revealed issue of children arriving in this country, but at least a start has been made on an issue known about and camapigned about for year and years.
Tom Brake’s comments here are inaccurate:
‘Only on the rare occasions when a family was denied entry at the border and there was no immediate return flight, have they been held in pre-departure accommodation until the next available flight, usually within 24 to 48 hours.’
In fact, where families are denied entry at the border they would normally be detained in Tinsley House Immigration Removal Centre near Gatwick Airport. In addition to this, the Government has built a new detention facility to house families in Crawley, Sussex, which they describe as ‘pre-departure accomodation.’ Typically families are picked up in dawn enforcement raids and taken to this detention facility where they can be held for up to a week. The children who are arrested in these raids may have been born and brought up in the UK. Undoubtedly the time limit of one week is an improvement on the previous situation where there was no time limit on detention, but immigration detention can never be a suitable place for a child, and many problems with the system remain.
A large proportion of families who are detained are subsequently released into the community, raising serious questions about why they were detained in the first place. My organisation (Bail for Immigration Detainees) is also working with large numbers of families who are separated when a parent is detained and children remain in the community with another parent or a foster carer. We also have serious concerns about Government policies on use of force against children during detention and attempts to remove them from the UK.
The situation for children and families will be hugely exacerbated next year when, as a result of the Legal Aid Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act, parents and children making immigration claims will no longer be able to access Legal Aid. Unaccompanied children who cannot pay for representation will have to represent themselves in court.