Category Archives: The LDV debate

The LDV debate: Is the Human Rights Act undemocratic and illiberal? – Part two – this time it’s Thai fish

summer extravaganza

The legendary Newbury & West Berkshire Liberal Democrat Summer Extravangaza, in idyllic surroundings, reaches its climax last Saturday with the drawing of the 200 club winners by local spokesperson Judith Bunting. But, beneath the genteel veneer, a member of the LDV team was disquietly seething with indignation over an assault on the credentials of the European Convention on Human Rights

We published an article by David Cooper on May 20th under by the title The Human Rights Act – undemocratic and illiberal.

There was an excellent debate in the comments thread underneath the article.

After being approached by David over Thai fish at the Newbury and West Berkshire Liberal Democrats Summer Extravaganza, I started the following correspondence on the matter, which David has given his permission for me to publish.

Tagged , and | 51 Comments

Recent Comments

  • John Marriott
    @Peter Martin You obviously have a short or indeed selective memory. That’s always been my position. Now, how about answering my question regarding your asse...
  • Katharine Pindar
    Catherine, thank you for your support, but ours was definitely a business motion, asking the party to set up a Commission. Michael Berwick-Gooding and I had sen...
  • David Evans
    @Paul Holmes. Hi Paul, thanks for the compliment, but I think on this occasion you are reading something into my post that is not actually there, though I can ...
  • Peter Martin
    @ John Marriott, "As I have written before, the way things are going, there might not be an EU to rejoin in a few years time!" I don't remember...
  • Ian Jones
    This internal debate is an inevitable consequence of Leaving the EU and the essential strategic recalibration now required because ' we are not a member of the ...