HM Treasury admits it doesn’t know how much money it’s spending: encore

Over the summer I blogged about the Treasury’s curious admission that it doesn’t know how much money it spends on, in the words of the question, “branding and marketing”. This week Dizzy Thinks spotted another example; the Treasury doesn’t know how much it spends on heating, electricity or water either. Perhaps it would be easier for someone to just ask what it does know?

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in News.
Advert

8 Comments

  • Why am I not surprised?

    Some years ago I got a job with a household-name state-owned company just weeks before it was privatised. They too had only the most rudimentary accounting system; it could just about say how much money came in and how much went out but anything inbetween was pretty much a mystery.

    It also turned out that even the most senior staff didn’t know how to evaluate a capital project even though capital spending was a large part of total spending at the time.

    I didn’t stay long!

  • I don’t see any reason for it to be an ‘inherent’ flaw. If ministers spent just a little time and effort thinking about efficiency (or at least requiring their departments to do so) then govt would run a whole lot better. Sadly, the culture seems to be to regard the taxpayer as a bottomless money-well.

  • Good question.

    My guess is that too many (all?) ministers prefer to rush out a response to any “something must be done” headline in the media without pausing to consider alternatives, especially if the best alternative is likely to be a harder initial sell.

    Absent a very clear and determined lead from the PM that value matters over spin, this tendency will soon become the rule. Blame Blair for exacerbating an existing trend.

    The implication is that this leaves an open goal for a party with a credible committment to value for money. We can’t in any case go on as before – that way lies national bankruptcy.

  • I didn’t say “there are no structural problems”. In fact I think the opposite – that there are enormous structural problems and that there is no particular reason to think one Party’s ministers would somehow be systematically better than another party’s ministers.

    However, that said the cultural problem that afflicts all parties is so deep that it amounts almost to a structural problem in itself – culture becomes structure.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Christopher Burden
    SR: "The UK is an independent country" No! Or in a narrow, legalistic sense only. Britain, long ago, became utterly dependent on favourable trade with . . e...
  • David Murray
    My concern is that a tough line from the USA could backfire if too much pressure is put on China. There has always been an implicit threat of the takeover of Ta...
  • Simon Robinson
    @Steve: Regarding Ukraine and Russia, you might want to consider which country was the one that invaded the other one before making absurd statements like "use ...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Thank you for a thought and question provoking article. Might it be that the U. S. A. Has a “root” policy of controlling the world for the basic benefit ...
  • PM
    " many who have voted Conservative over the past decades have done so simply because they could not engage with a hopelessly class conscious and arguably a...