Independent View: Health Bill doesn’t have to be a poisoned chalice, just put patients first

For all the face time that health secretary Andrew Lansley gets, Lib Dems can’t forget that come election time, they’ll be judged by the success or failure of the NHS reform package too.

This isn’t a reality that many members of the party are warming to. After almost a year of being cast by both the public and media in the role of scapegoat or political cover for their coalition partners, nobody can blame them for being wary.

But the Health and Social Care Bill doesn’t have to be a poisoned chalice. The Lib Dems have succeeded in securing compromises in other policy areas, and can earn the electorate’s respect by ensuring all the Government’s talk of ‘patient-centred’ reforms are backed up by real patient-centred policy.

That means listening to what patients really want.

Patient Opinion’s report ‘In their words: What patients think of our NHS’ took over 11,000 pieces of feedback on NHS services over the last five years and used it to find the main areas that are cause for concern, where patients perceive the NHS needs to improve.

Poor staff attitude was the most common complaint, raised by one in three patients who posted a negative story, and insufficient compassion and poor communication between staff and patient also rated highly.

These are all personable factors that depend on staff behaviour, not financial investment or organisational restructuring on a massive scale. By comparison, merely three per cent of negative comments raised ‘choice of provider’ as a problem.

The facts leave a gap in the market for Liberal Democrat policy makers to ensure Lansley’s conviction that improvement only comes through choice and competition does not leave patients with disintegration and disillusion.

Councillor Jon Rogers said the Department of Health proposals draw together “themes that Liberal Democrats have been campaigning on for many years such as putting patients at the heart of the NHS [and] focussing on improving outcomes rather than hitting targets”.

It is true that improving outcomes in the eyes of the patient is an improvement on chasing top down targets, but the Lib Dems need to listen to what patients are actually saying in reports like Patient Opinion’s to find out what exactly needs to be addressed to improve patients’ experience.

If they can succeed in championing the cause of patients in policy discussions, the rewards will be greater come election time.

Paul Hodgkin is a former GP and CEO of Patient Opinion

Want to share your NHS experience or compare account from other patients who were treated at your local hospital? Visit www.patientopinion.org.uk

Read more by .
This entry was posted in The Independent View.
Advert

2 Comments

  • The Tories want the NHS to be privatised, the Lib Dems will agree to this. It was in no party’s manifesto. Is this New Politics? Democracy? If I were still a Lib Dem supporter I’d be looking forward to he next election less and less.

  • If you don’t want it to be a poisoned chalice I suggest you start here…

    Conference regrets that some of the proposed reforms have never been Liberal Democrat policy, did not feature in our manifesto or in the Coalition agreement, which instead called for an end to large-scale top-down reorganisations.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • Alex Hosking
    TBF, I don't think either side is great on free speech these days, so many people don't get it and just resort to ad hominem. It would be good if we as a part b...
  • graham
    Thanks Mark. I too enjoyed the film Conclave which is based on Robert Harris`s novel of the same name which is a page turner. Like the previous film "Two Popes"...
  • Daniel Stylianou
    Morgan - looking to the Australian model doesn’t really help because members of their Senate are directly elected, just as in the US system. It goes back to t...
  • Craig Levene
    Sarah Campion, Dan Carden , Andy Burnham. Have all called for a further enquiry, & rightly so. Reading Dan's statement, it certainly resonates. These horrif...
  • Paul Barker
    Just on the point of comparison, I know from experience that German Trains are much worse than those around London & The South-East. Again, they seem to ha...