Lib Dems vs Brexit: Malcolm Bruce – Time to modernise our democracy

My Lords, across the UK, Scotland and London voted most strongly for remain, which is somewhat ironic given the nationalists’ antipathy towards London and London-based government. ​Northern Ireland voted clearly for remain, only to find its hard-line Brexit party tweaking the tail of a Brexit-traumatised Conservative Government. A lot has been said, I think rightly, about Theresa May’s and Jeremy Corbyn’s cavalier disregard for those who voted remain. “You lost. Get over it”, they say, but they have been unable to come up with anything that can unite a majority. When the DUP is challenged for representing a minority in Northern Ireland, it asserts that remain voters are predominantly nationalists and can therefore apparently be discounted—second-class votes.

Membership of the EU resides with the United Kingdom and it is not possible for parts of the UK to be in and parts to be out. I suggest that raises the question as to whether we should ever have sought a simple binary majority, or one that was qualified by the views of the constituent parts of the United Kingdom as well.

During a recent visit to Derry, I was able to see and hear how differences already affect what is located on which side of the border and how people and services operate. Moderate unionists who voted remain are beginning to consider whether the complexities of Brexit might make the prospect of a united Ireland unexpectedly attractive, especially now they see a much more liberal Republic and a frozen conservative Province in the north. The polarisation of Northern Ireland politics has left the Province without a democratic voice. Disillusioned young people at an integrated school that I visited in Derry told me that they thought that violence would return to the Province. I was quite shocked that they were unanimous in their view.

For a long time—the noble Lord, Lord Lisvane, referred to this—many people thought that nationalism could be contained within the European Union or at least under its umbrella. That is kind of logical given that the raison d’être of the European Union was to find mechanisms to avoid conflicts getting out of control and leading to war—which has been one of its great achievements.

For many years, the SNP campaigned under the slogan, “Independence in Europe”, so leaving the EU is a problem for it. First, a significant proportion of its voters chose Brexit. Secondly, leaving the UK without the comfort of the EU umbrella could leave Scotland in a cold place, with no prospect of a quick re-entry into the EU. Campaigners in favour of remain have sometimes prayed in aid divergence with Scotland as a threat to the union in simplistic terms. The people of Scotland voted remain by a large margin. Theresa May’s dead deal, something similar or no deal would in many ways be a betrayal of Scotland, or at least an insensitive disregard for the concerns and preferences of its people. Of course, that is seized on by the SNP to make the case for a second independence referendum. “Let’s vote for independence and rejoin the EU”, it says, except it is not that simple. First, the UK is overwhelmingly Scotland’s biggest market. Secondly, however sympathetic the EU may be to Scotland’s warmth towards that Union—in contrast with the SNP’s hostility to this union—Scotland would have to take years and deep economic pain before it could accede to membership, during which time it would be outside both unions.​

Surely it is time, Brexit or not, to sort out the mess that the United Kingdom has become and to create a constitution worthy of its name, which guarantees the human rights of everyone in the United Kingdom and accommodates the views and wishes of the devolved Administrations and the regions of England in a legal framework. The Bill in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Lisvane, is a good start. I understand why he asserts that nothing could challenge the sovereignty of this United Kingdom Parliament, but I think that he would recognise that, if it were a matter of a transition to a federal Government, we would eventually need a constitution to which even this House and the other House would have to be subordinated. That is how most modern democracies work. Ours is not working; it is time that we modernised it.

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in News.
Advert

3 Comments

  • Hear, hear.
    A lot has been said about those people who voted Brexit because it was the first time their voice would be heard.
    Well, I’ve got news for them. I first voted in 1979 and my vote has never been heard. I live in a one party state. My district council is Tory, my County Council is Tory and my Constituency has been Tory for over 100 years.
    I voted Remain and my voice and the rest of the 48% has been totally ignored. If you consider the different types of Leave that people voted for Remain actually won. What Nigel Farage and Jacob Rees-Mogg voted for is very different to what many other people voted for.
    The first past the post system has to change. The regions must have devolved power like Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. London gets 10x per capita spend on transport of that of the north. It’s unfair, unreasonable and needs to change.
    Everyone’s vote should have the same power. Governments are decided by 20 or30 marginal constituencies. The rest of us don’t count – literally.

  • Mary Tucker 20th Jan '19 - 5:10pm

    Safe seats are the biggest problem in our democracy . I wonder if there could be a solution by only allowing the same MP to be re-elected to serve the constituency for only two or three terms . This would still be a maximum of 15 years. Rather like a Methodist circuit they need not be deselected but move on to canvass in another constituency.

  • Well said, Malcolm. We’re never going to please everyone. A new comprehensive codified constitution delivered by the people with strict and fair rules, overseen by an independent judiciary is the best we are going to get.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User Avatarchris moore 21st Nov - 2:22pm
    I am one of a small minority of Lib Dem members, who though a Remainer, thought that we should have worked towards a compromise deal...
  • User AvatarFrank West 21st Nov - 2:17pm
    Well done, an actual policy that addresses a real problem rather than the more usual vague pronouncements. Energy company standing charges should similarly be abolished...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 21st Nov - 2:15pm
    John Marriott You said "This ‘Stop Brexit’ albatross around the Lib Dems’ necks may yet come back to haunt them." The key word is "them"....
  • User Avatarchris moore 21st Nov - 2:07pm
    Lastly, the creeping in of defeatism from a few posters on here on the back of a few negative polls is unfortunate and pre-mature. It's...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 21st Nov - 2:04pm
    Labour has accepted that its manifesto needs to be costed, which is good, so far. It is a long document, which takes hours to read....
  • User AvatarDavid Raw 21st Nov - 2:04pm
    @ Martin Your comment to John. "Put your thinking cap on and just explain what this referendum would consist of and how you it would...