Local elections in Scotland: the key battlegrounds

Every Council seat in Scotland is up for grabs tomorrow.  There are currently 152 Liberal Democrat councillors in 23 of the 32 local authorities, from the Highlands to Dumfries and Galloway. Liberal Democrats are participants in 13 coalition administrations.

Five years ago, there was some trepidation about how these coalitions would work. It was predicted that they would fall apart in months, but most have lasted the course. The naysayers were mainly from the Labour party, who had lost many of their traditional fiefdoms thanks to the introduction of STV, brought in at the insistence of the Liberal Democrats following the 2003 Holyrood elections when the party formed its second coalition with Labour.

Only a few bastions of Labour majority rule remain. The biggest is Glasgow, but the party faces heavy losses to the SNP. Its troubled administration fell apart in the first few months of this year when several councillors resigned from the ruling group and are standing against official Labour candidates. There are currently five Liberal Democrat councillors there who may well end up holding the balance of power. Group Leader Paul Coleshill has performed well in several TV debates and hustings.

Edinburgh has been run by a Lib Dem/SNP coalition for the last five years. Jenny Dawe, the Council leader, wrote on LDV around 18 months ago of the shock of discovering that Labour had plundered the reserves and left the Council on the verge of bankruptcy. Sound familiar? As well as putting the Council on a more secure financial footing, the Liberal Democrats have made huge improvements in Edinburgh including:

  • reduced homelessness and building the first Council houses in a generation
  • increased school attainment
  • increased respite care by 13%
  • built 4 new care homes
  • introduced the Edinburgh Guarantee, a plan to find training, college place or job for every school leaver

Inevitably, the troubled trams project will be a factor. The trams should have been running by now, but it will be 2014 before the first one takes to the tracks. Beset by contractual problems which took far too long to resolve, the trams are well over budget. However, it’s the Liberal Democrat administration which has shown leadership and actually sorted the problems out.

In the Scottish elections last year, the loss of our seats in the Highlands was a huge blow. At Council level,  the Liberal Democrat record is impressive. We had to come to the rescue when the SNP walked away from administration in 2008 when the going got tough. Despite financial challenges, the party has saved key services like libraries and swimming pools by putting them in the control of an arms length organisation and has led Scotland in working with the NHS to provide integrated care services for adults.

Scottish Liberal Democrats will almost certainly end up with fewer councillors on Friday – because we are standing fewer candidates. In many wards where we stood 2 candidates before, we’re only standing one. The SNP are standing many more. They could actually have won significantly more seats in 2007  if they’d stood more candidates and they are stronger now than they were then. However, there are signs that the shine is starting to come off. Last year they achieved 44.7% of the vote. The recent YouGov poll for the Sunday Times showed them at 35% for the Council elections, down 9.7%. Admittedly it was a very small sample, but the revelation of the extent of Alex Salmond’s involvement with Rupert Murdoch at the Leveson Enquiry last week may well be having an impact. In addition, their leader in Glasgow, Allison Hunter, said recently that “Everything the SNP does is, of course, a stepping stone towards independence.” This may not go down too well with people who care about the care their elderly parents receive, or their children’s schooling, or good transport networks.

Willie Rennie has performed extremely well in his first year of leadership – securing £40 million extra in funding for Scotland’s colleges, challenging the SNP on their plans to merge Scotland’s 8 Police forces into one and speaking out when Alex Salmond played down News International’s involvement in phone hacking. He’s regularly hailed in the press as being the most effective opposition leader.

In addition, Scots have just had a tax cut or a £5.30 a week increase in their state pension courtesy of the Liberal Democrats in the Westminster Government.

There’s no doubt that our councillors have achieved much in the last five years and have a strong record of action for their communities. We’ll know on Friday if that connection and hard work has been enough.

The votes will be counted during the day on Friday so I’ll keep you posted with the results.

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Nicola Prigg 2nd May '12 - 1:58pm

    I would add there are areas where we will gain in the share of the vote due to actually standing candidates this time around.

  • It is actually much more complicated than that. 2 candidates getting 500 first preferences does not mean that one candidate will get 1000 first prefs. A certain proportion of a candidate’s vote will be a personal rather than a party vote. 2 candidates means two lots of personal votes rather than one. More and more people vote for the person rather than the party. Not all first preferences transfer to other candidates of the same party. Only a proportion will do so and many will not transfer at all.

    All the main parties in Scotland now make very careful calculations about what the optimal number of candidates to stand in STV elections are. They don’t always get it right – particularly if they do a lot better or a lot worse than they expect.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Peter Martin
    @ Katharine, " ...young people should be informed that, with the present Labour leadership, they should not expect too much from a new Labour government...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Well posted Mr. Gray!!! Why is it that an adult being offended in London gets lots of publicity while children in Gaza having limbs amputated without anaesth...
  • Chris Lewcock
    Seems a facile and false parallel is being drawn between imposing seatbelts and banning cigarettes. Requiring use of a seat belt doesn't ban driving, doesn't re...
  • Peter Martin
    On the question of salary vs dividend payments: "Many directors choose to take the majority of their income in the form of dividends, as this is usually more...
  • Gwyn Williams
    Nigeria already has a population in 2022 of 219 million by 2050 some projections show it growing to 377 million. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1122955/for...