Lib Dem leader Ming Campbell is on Radio 4’s consumer programme You and Yours right now.
If you’re listening, why not tell us what you think?
Subscribe
-
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
-
Like us on Facebook
-
Subscribe to our feed
-
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Most Read
Search
Op-eds
-
What can we really do to influence the situation in the West Bank? (Alan Juriansz)
-
Welcome to Lib Dem Friends of Gaelic Language and Culture (Caron Lindsay)
-
Going for four in a row in Scotland (Grant Toghill)
-
Lib Dems call for action on smart spectacles – some constructive feedback (Caron Lindsay)
-
AI has moved from future threat to present reality (Sean Worrell)
-
The Joy of Six 1571
-
Same old, same old from Farage
-
How Long Has it been?
-
Oh no, not another by-election
-
Restoration of Gone to Earth to be shown in London Film Festival
-
Lib Dem policy is light on politics not on outside expertise
-
Back to Sandy Campbell and Tsar Nicholas II
-
Discovery
-
Starmer makes the ultimate betrayal
-
Tŷ Newydd National Writing Centre's Open Day - 27 September 2026
Recent Comments
Simon Robinson
London isn't all the same. I think what @Josh says is broadly true of central London out to maybe TfL Zone 4, where much of the population is young, transient, ...- Simon Robinson
@Peter Davies: I think you're probably correct. Checking on MapIt, it looks like the Holborn and St Pancras constituency contains Euston, St Pancras and Kings C... 
Maurice Leeke
In the words of Max Boyce “I was there”. I found your rendition of “Ode to Joy” at An Talla Mhòr very moving. To my shame I didn’t recognise you, I...
William Wallace
Was the Gaelic spoken in the SouthWest of Scotland the same variant? I understood that this was a Celtic version closer to Welsh. Wallace means Welsh, for what ...
Peter Davies
Zack Polanski has now said he will stand. We really need to take him on directly....
6 Comments
“A great deal of e-mails and texts on proportional representation – why doesn’t Ming talk about it more?”
Only on Radio 4!
He then did, but only in response to the question. But his comments were directed at what Lib Dems had achieved in Scotland, without explaining the benefits of PR. And the Scottish regional list system is hardly PR anyway…
Didn’t he also mention STV at local elections in Scotland? That’s the far bigger achievement, in my view, particularly since that worked quite well in the most recent elections, and the regional list system went rather less well.
Yes, he did, Alex. But he might also have mentioned that STV put an end to one-party monopoly of power in many councils, forcing councilors to work together: gave people the chance to express their preferences among candidates of the same party etc etc.
I think he fell into the trap, as we so often do, of failing to relate a successful policy initiative with our principles. If we do things just because they seem technically better, then we are no different from Tories and Labour.
Why do I keep on saying to myself (and sometimes to one of my ward’s LD Councillors) that LD leaders, national and local, just keep on missing the tricks? By all accounts Ming did that again today. Get yourselves some training in putting the message over. (I am, and will remain, a supporter but not a party member.)
This must be the first time any Lib Dem has ever been criticised for not taking enough about PR!