William Powell considers the issue of the many thousands of workers in the UK who had no vote in the #Brexit Referendum – but who are living with its consequences
Quantifying the problem of hate crime
Over the summer, I received several disturbing reports ranging from school yard taunting of the children of EU nationals about ‘returning home’ post Brexit right through to criminal damage of commercial premises. In the light of this, I took the opportunity to ask Cllr Barry Thomas, Leader of Powys County Council, a question on reported incidents of hate crime at Full Council last month. Given the need to keep our communities secure, tolerant and welcoming, I asked what specific measures are being promoted within the Powys Public Service Board, to combat intolerance and prejudice, in furtherance of the Wellbeing of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015. This followed a useful meeting that Cllr Thomas and I had with newly elected Dyfed-Powys Police and Crime Commissioner, Dafydd Llewelyn, at the Royal Welsh Show.
Climate of uncertainty and apprehension
What prompted me to ask the question is the ongoing climate of uncertainty and apprehension, evident amongst sections of our population, in Powys, Wales and across the UK. The playground taunting that was brought to my attention may have been an isolated incident in that school – but by its nature, this kind of name calling and worse is likely to go underreported. We need therefore to be extra alert to signs of it. The minutes of the local Community Safety Partnership indicate a significant spike in hate crime in midsummer, with 12 referrals to Victim Support in June 2016, compared with 8 the previous year. These incidents took place in the immediate aftermath of the 23rd June – tying in with similar incident statistics across Wales and the UK. Clearly the febrile atmosphere unleashed by the Referendum campaign had played its part.
Unleashing the prejudices of the few
Most Leave voters, including many whom I would count as friends, had reasons for their choice – and would roundly condemn any hostility towards EU Nationals, or indeed any other minority groups caught up in the cross fire. However, it has become apparent that a small minority of individuals, who have always harboured prejudices, are emboldened, in the post Brexit climate, to give voice to them, regardless of the feelings of others. Whilst it seems that the surge in such incidents has ebbed, the overall atmosphere in our communities, our work places and even our schools, remains potentially vulnerable to fresh waves of such sentiment. This is a particular danger, should our economic circumstances deteriorate.
Spontaneous displays of kindness
At times over the summer, by contrast, I have seen spontaneous displays of kindness and thoughtfulness at community level. This was manifested memorably when Talgarth Town, my local football team, hosted a friendly against Unity in Diversity, a Swansea based refugee team back in July. Similarly, a young Polish Mum cried as she told me about the flood of text messages that her daughter had received from school mates, offering friendship and support in the Brexit aftermath.
We all have a part to play
So it is clear that we are all able to make a contribution towards safeguarding the kind of decent, tolerant society that we would wish to live in. Especially in our schools, teachers, governors and parents can be alert to these matters in their own communities. I am not convinced that the Home Office’s ‘Prevent’ strategy, which targets radicalisation, is well adapted to combatting home grown nationalism, jingoism and ignorance. We need bespoke strategies to challenge these behaviours – and this task should be on the agenda of our Public Service Boards.
Valuing our EU Nationals
The First Minister, the Rt Hon Carwyn Jones AM, has repeatedly stated that Wales values the presence and contribution of many thousands of EU Nationals and others to our communities and our public services, notably in the healthcare sector. My Welsh Liberal Democrat colleague Kirsty Williams AM, as Cabinet Secretary for Education in the Welsh Government, has recently emphasised too the importance of EU students to the sustainability of our universities – and our farming and automotive sectors remain heavily reliant on EU exports, regardless of the theology of Brexit. The recent events around Nissan are a powerful reminder of this.
Remembrance – in its widest sense
As communities across the UK prepare to recall the sacrifices made for the freedom and tolerance of our society, there is maybe more than ever to reflect upon this year. The mass slaughter of the last century reminds us of what can happen when nation states pursue their interests unfettered and come off the rails. The 11th November is, of course, also Polish Independence Day, when Poles recall winning their freedom from domination by more powerful neighbours. Poland’s contribution to our own struggle against fascism is a proud part of our shared history. In recent days, the German Embassy in London has reported a significant rise in those of German Jewish heritage in the UK applying for German and therefore EU citizenship to which they are entitled under the German Grundgesetz. Whatever their motivation, this move should cause all those of us who care about the reputation of our country abroad a sharp intake of breath.
Not only common decency, but also common sense
For these – and so many other reasons – it is not only common decency, but also common sense, for us to remain mindful of the feelings and anxieties of our fellow residents, and to call out unacceptable behaviours, as we navigate our way through the post Referendum world.
* Cllr William Powell is President of the Welsh Liberal Democrats
10 Comments
“Slaughter” can be read in context as the horrors of the Holocaust, but could be plural.
German Grundgesetz: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Law_for_the_Federal_Republic_of_Germany
A good article, thank you for publishing it.
We need to guarantee EU migrant rights. It can be hard to understand their level of fear if you haven’t spoken to one, but it is high.
Three main fears I’ve picked up on from speaking to a relative who is also an EU migrant:
1. Residency rights
2. Racism, discrimination, abuse and attacks
3. Getting rid of the human rights act. I didn’t think this one would be much of a concern but they seem to think this will be used to make it easier to deport them and legalise discrimination or reduce protections (British jobs for British workers).
There’s an old saying that actions speak louder in words and when the people of Wales voted on June 23rd, they most certainly did not demonstrate that Wales “values the presence and contribution of many thousands of EU Nationals” but, rather, the opposite. As one EU citizen put it – EU citizens are a minority of the immigrants here, yet, they were singled out and made a scapegoat whereas the larger number of non-EU immigrants are completely ignored in our political discussions.
I welcome immigration, its a good thing. I’d like like more control over the flows of immigration, simply to be able to plan out future infrastructure and services required ( the Gisela Stuart view point).
I wish Teresa May would come out and state clearly that all European citizens currently living in the UK can continue to live exactly the same lives without any disruption and with full rights guaranteed. additionally after brexit occurs, all EU citizens who have been living and working in the UK have an automatic right to apply for duel citizenship of the UK and the EU ( David Davies position).
I deplore the rise in isolated hate crimes. I also deplore the feeling of not being wanted that some EU citizens have felt ( i work with Latvians, Lithuanians, Poles, Spanish.. .all good people). I deplore the idea that because I want the final decision making powers to be returned the the entity of the UK that this somehow means I don’t want the UK to be open and welcoming ( the two positions do not have (are not) to be linked to each other)
I understand that Theresa May wants to make sure there is mutual grantee for British expats living and working in the EU. I just wish the UK and EU would take this deeply personal and seemingly simple issue off the table and guarantee continuation, full rights and future dual citizenship’s for all and reassure everyone!
While far less important compared to stories of hate crime, the number of EU citizens who have a right to be here but are now looking at spending time and sometimes money filling in immigration forms which do little more than (and often not even that) confirm they have a right to be here should also be looked at. It is creating work for the home office and solicitors but who is really benefiting?
Ethicsgradient, as a fellow Leaver I fully endorse your comments. I signed the petition that is up and running to pressure the government to announce that all EU citizens currently here will be able to stay. Lord Howard has called for the same.
I am sure Mrs May is concerned about UK nationals in EU countries, and securing reciprocal rights, and this is understandable. But actually our EU citizens resident and working here in the UK are more important. The UK nationals abroad must abide by whatever laws pertain there. Not great if those laws change, but still not as important as people in the UK.
Please all sign the petition.
Thanks Bill. A very much needed article!
Thanks Bill for highlighting hate crime against EU nationals. I have heard there is a severe increase of incidents since the referendem on 23 June 2016. The biggest problem is that most people do not report hate crime.
I suggest all leavers look up the story of Pandora’s box because like Pandora you’ve opened the box and bad things have flown out; now while I’m more than happy to try to stuff them back into the box with you, I think it would be unfair while I’m doing it to ask me to not point out it was pretty stupid to open it in the first place.