Tag Archives: carol thatcher

LDV readers say: BBC not justified in banning Carol Thatcher

Last week, in the wake of the whipped-up hysteria surrounding Carol Thatcher being banned by the BBC from The One Show for using the term ‘golliwog’, LDV asked our readers if you thought the corporation was justified in its actions.

Here’s how you voted:

Yes, the BBC was justified – 44% (116 votes)
No, the BBC wasn’t justified – 52% (139)
Don’t know – 4% (11)
Total Votes: 266. Poll ran: 5th-10th February 2009

So, a bare majority of you think the BBC over-reacted to Carol Thatcher’s use of racially-loaded language.

The poll was picked-up by the Telegraph’s James Kirkup, who used it …

Posted in Voice polls | Also tagged and | 7 Comments

NEW POLL: was the BBC right to ban Carol Thatcher from The One Show?

I’ve avoided for as long as possible the uber-hyped ‘nowtrage’ over Carol Thatcher’s off-air-but-in-the-studio comment that a still-to-be-identified tennis player looks like a ‘golliwog’.

It does of course pose lots of interesting questions for liberals: the conflict between freedom of speech, and the offence that may cause; to what extent unbroadcast behind-the-scenes remarks should be regarded as private; whether remarks that cause offence are best dealt with by individuals at the time, rather than by being referred to an ombudsmanperson.

The Lib Dem blogosphere has wrestled with many of these issues and more, and given more time to …

Posted in Voice polls | Also tagged , , , , and | 15 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • Denis Mollison
    @Jeremy It is nothing to do with anti-Semitism! The racism is on Israel's side, rightly described as apartheid. And we should take action because of our histori...
  • David Evans
    David Raw, you ask a very pertinent set of questions about Ed's voting record. I actually had the chance to ask him in a hustings meeting the Question "Why whe...
  • Simon Mostyn
    This is my first contribution to Lib Dem Voice so I thought I would choose a non-contentious subject to begin with. I have friends and family living in Israe...
  • Nonconformistradical
    @Jeremy Chambers "t’s an issue for Israel and Palestine to deal with, not for the UK to interfere with in the same way we would not expect Israel to interfer...
  • Helen Dudden
    I agree, I pray for peace. The many year's I have had my beliefs insulted, has been incredible. As I said to a contact in Israel, I hate violence, the answe...