Tag Archives: craig johnson

Reasons to be careful about new analysis suggesting Lib Dems “set to lose several more seats than national polls with uniform swing would predict”

A new analysis by Oxford academic Stephen Fisher (a member of the team which was behind the scarily accurate BBC/ITN exit poll at the 2010 election) douses the comfort blanket to which many of us Lib Dems have been clinging, suggesting as it does that the Lib Dems are losing more votes in our strongest seats:

The most significant factor affecting party performance at the constituency level is prior Liberal Democrat strength. … the Liberal Democrats are clearly loosing most in the seats where they started strongest and losing least where they started weakest. Partly this is inevitable. There are over 100 seats where the Lib Dems got less than 16% of the vote in 2010 and so their vote share cannot fall by this much. Moreover it is unlikely that the party will fall exactly to zero even where it does very badly. So if the GB polls are right overall, the Liberal Democrats must be falling more where they started stronger, and the BES data suggest the drop is broadly proportional to their prior strength. This mirrors the pattern of change at the local authority level at the European Parliament elections this year, adding confidence that the effect is real. The implications for Liberal Democrat seats are straightforward. If they are indeed losing most heavily in the seats they are defending they are set to lose several more seats than national polls with uniform swing would predict.

Posted in Polls | Also tagged , , and | 81 Comments

A longer read for the weekend: How important will incumbency be to the Lib Dems in 2015?

Liberal Democrat badge - Some rights reserved by Paul Walter, Newbury, UKLast year I wrote a piece, So, about that Lib Dem wipeout in 2015 then…, highlighting that – though the polls are grim for the Lib Dems – the assumption of many pundits that this will automatically translate into Lib Dem annihilation at the next election is flawed.

That brief analysis was based on looking at the lists of Lib Dem-held seats that Labour and the Tories are targeting. Now Craig Johnson from Newcastle University has taken a more …

Posted in Party policy and internal matters and What do the academics say? | Also tagged and | 8 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • Tom Harney
    I welcome this report about Alistair Carmichael’s comments on the present situation. If it is said that the prime minister is in a different category than he...
  • John Medway
    @Jeff I have found your post very informative, about both J Redwood and the detailed workings of the EU - thanks. @Gordon Analogies for money like fuel, lubr...
  • Helen Dudden
    The problem with not telling the truth, is you have to remember lie. Lies come to the surface sooner or later. In the Commons there needs to be thoughts, on...
  • Nonconformistradical
    @Catherine Jane Crosland "It seems rather harsh to say “the whole party is rotten” (of the conservatives). Surely there are plenty of decent, honourable co...
  • Martin
    There can be very little positive in tolerating a Prime Minister that lies to parliament, just as there is next to nothing positive in giving a free pass to min...