Tag Archives: minority government

Alistair Carmichael MP writes…The truth about those “secret Tory talks”

A couple of weeks ago I was due to meet with one of my counterparts in the Conservative whips office. These meetings are routine and are not normally the subject of comment.  This particular meeting was intended to deal with allocation of offices between the parties for MPs to use. In fact the meeting did not go ahead although I DID meet the Government Chief Whip’s Private Secretary (known inside the bubble as the usual channels).

The meeting that did not happen (mundane though it was) somehow found its way into the Daily Mail who proceeded to speculate wildly about whether the meeting was indeed a sign that the Lib Dems were now cosying up to the Tories to stitch up a secret coalition deal.

Of course at that time the Conservatives were trying to negotiate a deal with the DUP, negotiations were going badly (due mostly to their own mismanagement).  Briefing the press in this way was a mark of the desperation with which they were seized.

So when I read in the Times yesterday that Tim Farron’s chief of staff Ben Williams had met with his No 10 counterpart Gavin Barwell last Thursday I took it with a pinch of salt. Not least because I knew that Ben was in Leeds on Thursday.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , and | 27 Comments

Opinion: Is a Minority government good for a progressive agenda and good for governance?

Most political commentators believe that the chances are that after the next election no party will have a majority. As we approach the election some people are suggesting that perhaps a new coalition government isn’t the best answer to promote progressive policies. The experiences of the Conservative-Liberal Democrat Coalition, and to a lesser extent the Labour/Plaid Cymru coalition that ran Wales from 2007-2011 have shown that a left leaning party has to make too many compromises when in a coalition.

Some people are actively discussing that perhaps a new coalition government isn’t the best answer to promote progressive policies. The experience of the Conservative-Liberal Democrat Coalition has shown that a left leaning party has to make too many compromises when in a coalition with a right of centre party.

This has resulted in an increasing discussion on the left that perhaps a minority government, as in Scotland from 2007-2011, might be a better chance for a progressive agenda. One positive outcome of this approach could be the re-establishment of a positive relationship between the general public and parliament. A minority government could strengthen parliament. Why do we say this? After having had a budget agreed, a minority government would have to create coalitions for every policy issue. This would enable real debate on issues and the possibility of creating a progressive agenda across political boundaries.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged and | 26 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarGeoffrey Dron 15th Sep - 3:51pm
    @David Dobbie - yes, but what sort of EU? An empire which will replace nation states? https://order-order.com/2019/09/14/lib-dems-applaud-call-eu-become-empire/ A lot of us 2016 remain voters would...
  • User AvatarPaul Walter 15th Sep - 3:51pm
    Automated responses are given. That’s the problem - they are automated. If I wanted to give money to a speak-your-weight machine I would walk down...
  • User AvatarPaul Barker 15th Sep - 3:42pm
    We have had 3 Mps each from Labour & The Tories, 4 of those defections in the last 12 Days. Its small beginnings but there...
  • User Avatarexpats 15th Sep - 3:38pm
    David Raw 15th Sep '19 - 2:34pm.................Time to encourage and support local authorities to build council houses again... I agree but WITHOUT the 'right to...
  • User AvatarAdam 15th Sep - 3:29pm
    "Parliamentary democracy should be representative, the responsibility of the representatives being as defined by Edmund Burke in his famous response to the electors of Bristol."...
  • User AvatarPaul Barker 15th Sep - 3:25pm
    I frequently send donations to HQ, I would be cross if I got a letter of thanks in return as it would be a waste...
Thu 10th Oct 2019