Author Archives: Nick Inman

The Independent View: Groundhog Day in the Lords?

Paul Tyler’s recent letter to the Guardian about reforming the House of Lords raises at least two meta questions about British politics.

He suggests Keir Starmer revives the 2012 Lib Dem legislation but before we do that should ask why did that initiative fail and why should things be different in 2024.

The truth is it, it failed for the same reasons that every previous attempt failed, starting in 1911 but most conspicuously in 1999 when a cohort of counts and their ilk managed to stay on in the second chamber.

Britain is very good at self-sabotage, at not learning from its previous mistakes. This is because its guiding constitutional principle is tradition, which is both infallible and a way of predicting the future.

There are 18 reasons/obstacles (maybe more) why reform failed in the past. If Starmer’s team is serious, it will have to dismantle these obstacles first.

There is not space to explain all the hobbles on Lords reform but I will give you three of them.

As soon as anyone progressive announces that they really are going to finish off the Lords, no ifs and buts, a stock objection will be made: there are more urgent priorities to deal with. The economy, stupid. The next government will inherit a crises in living standards; the NHS and the environment. These will take up all its time and money.

Related to this is a second objection: it is never a good time for constitutional reform which is widely seen as both unnecessary – if it ain’t broke you can’t fix it: unbelievably the Lords in its present form has its apologists – or risky. Throw out umpteen centuries of trial and error and there is a good chance that you’ll make things even worse.

Thirdly, the interests of a party in Opposition are very different to the those of a party in government. Win an election and you go from outsider to insider. The system is yours for a while; you can do what you want.  You lose interest in changing even the tiniest aspect of the system that has put you where you are. Why would you want to share or devolve power that you have just won unfairly and unsquarely?

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 4 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • expats
    I was under the impression that the Liberal Democrats still support lowering the voting age to 16 for all UK elections. If you can decide who runs a nation at ...
  • Keith Legg
    Genuine question here. The Welsh constitution requires that the leader must be either an MS or an MP. Given that Jane Dodds is the only MS, and David the onl...
  • Yunshu
    Thanks everyone for sharing your thoughts on this topic! This is my first article with Lib Dem Voice and I was sharing some insights based on discourse I've s...
  • Tony Hill
    I owe him a lot. In 1974 he interviewed me aof a job as a research assistant to the Liberal MPs. I didn't get it, and as a result met my partner of 47 years! ...
  • David Blake
    Sorry to hear this news. The last time I saw him was many years ago, in Blake Gardens in Bridgwater, where he was born. I sometimes wonder how the party would...