Green groups say all main parties failing on green leadership

Nick Clegg Cathkin MarshSeven key environment groups have given their verdict on the environmental performance of Cameron, Clegg and Miliband. Their report, Green Standard 2013, is pretty condemning.

After a promising first few months, the coalition government and the UK’s senior politicians have been largely silent about the UK’s environmental goals. The prime minister’s promise that he would lead “the greenest government ever” has been devalued by the chancellor’s framing of high environmental standards as a threat to economic success.

David Cameron is castigated for having failed to address climate change scepticism among members of his party. The green groups says he now needs to rebuild support in the party for a green agenda to reconnect with mainstream public opinion in the UK. Owen Paterson is singled out for “publicly rejecting evidence of human-induced climate change and, in doing so, threatens to undermine evidence-based policy making on this issue.”

The authors praise Labour for its work up to Copenhagen but castigate it for “treating environmental sustainability as a bolt-on to its main economic and social objectives.” They say Miliband is giving promising leadership on the low carbon economy, but has no programme for government.

For Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems, they say:

The Liberal Democrats have won some significant battles on climate change. But they need to develop a bolder and more holistic approach to environmental sustainability in government, particularly for the natural environment, if they wish to continue to claim to be a ‘green’ party. The leadership must defend the fourth carbon budget and deliver an energy framework compatible with decarbonisation. The importance of the environment for ensuring economic renewal should be heard from all senior Liberal Democrat ministers… The party needs to realise its ambition for localism, and address the lack of resources and expert support available for the local councils and local enterprise partnerships that are trying to go green.

The Lib Dems are criticised for having “not found a strong voice on the natural environment or demonstrated an impact from within the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.”

Crucially, strong rhetoric on energy has not been replicated in policy detail, with Ed Davey overseeing an energy policy framework that risks a high carbon lock-in incompatible with carbon budgets.

The environmental groups are particularly critical of the “whipped vote against decarbonisation target, contrary to party policy, and a continued willingness to tolerate, and even promote, subsidies for nuclear power.” They say there is “no leadership on the natural environment agenda, and worrying support for policies that damage wildlife.”

David Heath is condemned for “supporting the damaging and unscientific badger cull and buzzard nest destruction. He has also not insisted on effective government action to halt the catastrophic decline of bees and refused to support a ban on neonicotinoids.”

While the stance on biofuels is among the best of all the European member states, Vince Cable “has not supported the phase out of UK taxpayer support for international fossil fuel projects” and is supporting nuclear power.

* Andy Boddington is a Lib Dem councillor in Shropshire. He blogs at

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • “People power” is killing off the badger cull. It’s been an amazingly impressive effort from all sections of the community, bringing together people as diverse as hunt sabs and Tory activists in a common cause.

    I know about the Blue Badger Group. Where’s the LibDem equivalent?

    Please what are the LibDems doing to bring the disastrous, disgusting badger killing project to a quick, orderly end?

  • Anwar Ahmad Ansari 15th Sep '13 - 3:11pm

    The levy on plastic bags should be 10p per bag and must be implemented straight way.

  • daft ha'p'orth 15th Sep '13 - 4:06pm

    @Anwar Ahmad Ansari
    Why not a tenner and attendance at a mandatory re-education lecture on the risks of plastic bag use to sea life?

  • Peter Watson 15th Sep '13 - 4:12pm

    @Anwar Ahmad Ansari “The levy on plastic bags should be 10p per bag and must be implemented straight way.”
    I must admit, when the party leader trumpets a new green policy which is simply copying what the Welsh did two years ago, but delaying it for two more years and only applying it to supermarkets … well, it’s hardly inspiring, is it? Do blue and yellow really make green?

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Simon R
    To my mind, one ethical issue with a wealth tax is that, if your wealth was acquired legally, then you probably already paid tax on it when you first acquired i...
  • Big Tall Tim
    The ultra-purists who are complaining about the stunts, need to remember that what they have remembered, not what Ed said. The stunts are excellent and are bei...
  • Big Tall Tim
    You're wrong Russell. He's getting coverage, which otherwise we wouldn't. It's reminding voters it's more than the Rishi/Keir presidential contest....
  • Russell
    Davey needs to stop these ridiculous. The photos make him look" not serious"....
  • Andy Chandler
    Hi the author here. I pretty much agree with @Mick Taylor. Usually for third parties we traditionally attack the governing party in elections and I think this s...