Paying down the national debt: it’s always been a controversial issue. Here’s a Liberal poster (from the 1886 general election?) attacking the Tories for their failure to clear our debts:
For balance, here’s a Tory poster (from the same year?) accusing the Liberals of being high-spenders:
The nature of the debate doesn’t change much, but I think it’s fair to say they knew how to design political posters in those days. And in some ways we’re going back to the future as political parties make greater use of infographics to communicate messages which don’t fit into snappy one-line slogans.
(The images above are both from the LSE’s fascinating digitised collection of tariff reform posters.)
* Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall.
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Latest voting intention and leadership ratings opinion polls
More missing scientists: Remembering the GEC-Marconi deaths panic of the late Eighties
Makerfield: we can breathe again.
Brexit has cut trade in almost every sector of the UK economy
Mohammed Amin
Tom Bailey
Tristan Ward
Tristan Ward
8 Comments
This just shows that the affinity of Liberals with bar charts goes back much further than most people think.
The Liberal bar chart has a zero base, the Tory bar chart starts at 73! Plus ça change…
Have people just got dramatically dumber since then? These posters have precise data, they have well explained facts, that 2nd Tory chart even has a citation for the data at the bottom.
A real testament to the shallow stupidity of most of our political debates these days. No wonder in those days Britain ruled the world, and now we couldn’t organise a certain event in a brewery (to steal Mr Milliband’s expression).
@ Stephen W, we should remember the much smaller Electorate they were appealing to, somewhere between 10 & 20% of the adult population,we arent comparing like with like.
If you assume the electorate are stupid, and create political advertising that treats them like idiot children, then you have created a self-fulfilling prophecy. If, on the other hand, you actually use advertising to raise the electorate’s political intelligence, you might have a competition by the parties to use verifiable facts and figures to support their stances.
I should add that, after 1884, the electorate as a percentage of the adult population was more like 30% (or 60% of adult males).
Was red really associated with the Liberals in 1886, or was this just an arbitrary color choice that both chart-makers happened to use?
The Liberal poster is missing the strap-line : “If there was a Labour Party it can’t win here”
To answer David. Yes, Red WAS the Liberals campaigning colour up until the time labour stole it. And is the reason Rochdale still stick to it. Along with black, the old radical campaigning colour.
Ken.
The Tory poster is much more lies leading as the bar graph starts at 73 million pounds of money, and as a result distorts the differences between the 2 parties.
The Liberal Barnhart has more integrity as it starts from 0 as it should.