Musings from the Front Bench…

I have supported the Liberal Party and its successors since the General Election of 1950, although I did not follow a political career. Instead, I was involved in the railway and bus industries before moving into academia at the Universities of Salford and Oxford.

My entry to the House of Lords was a complete surprise. It took place over a two year period, and the process began with an interview with John Harris and Bill Rodgers, the then Chief Whip and Leader in the House respectively. Having been sworn to secrecy, I was asked firstly whether, if appointed, I would promise to attend on three days per week and then, having agreed, was asked about what I had done. I was by then a County Councillor in Oxfordshire, as well as a member of the Thames Valley Police Authority.

It was in July 1999 that my appointment was made. I took part in debates and questions about policing and transport and, about two years later, was made transport spokesperson. Since then I have worked with, I think, six members of the House of Commons who have held the transport portfolio. I don’t know why I was appointed but have done my best to represent the interests of the Party, attending for most votes and, I believe, getting on with my colleagues. I am seventy-four this year and commute daily from Oxfordshire. I enjoy being here immensely.

The House is a very polite place, and almost all Peers are friendly and helpful. There are some very obvious anomalies. However, I believe that the hereditary Peers should not be replaced, and that those who commit crimes should not be allowed to be members. There should be a voluntary retirement age and a properly independent Appointments Commission. David Steel has, on many occasions, introduced Bills to give effect to these changes but they have been resolutely resisted by many on the Labour and Conservative benches, as well as by some crossbenchers.

As a Front Bench spokesperson, I try to frame written and oral questions in an attempt to hold government to account, and it frequently requires persistence to get an answer. The Liberal Democrat Peers support one another and are distinguished by our high attendance level and the number of questions we put down and the amendments we move.

Whilst reform to bring about an elected second chamber is an aim of the Party, I am not sure that this would mean that the expertise needed would be available. I, and many of my colleagues, would never have considered contesting an election. The Whips here have little power as we are unsalaried and cannot be deselected. We do scrutinise every Bill and can speak on any amendment. Speakers and amendments are not selected by the Lord Speaker, neither is there a guillotine.

I believe that much reform must be carried out in the Commons before we touch the Lords, and we must strive to ensure that any elections attract good talent rather than just the cast-offs from the Commons. We also need to settle the issue of the nature of the relationship between an elected House of Lords and the Commons.

Lord (Bill) Bradshaw was, before arriving in the Lords, a former General Manager of British Rail’s Western Region and was one of the people interviewed by Ian Hislop in his 2008 documentary about the Beeching cuts of the early sixties, ‘Ian Hislop Goes off The Rails’. By a curious coincidence, the film’s director, Deborah Lee, is the daughter of Liberal Democrat Peer, Lord Lee of Trafford…

Read more by or more about , , , , or .
This entry was posted in Parliament.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarPaul Fisher 23rd Feb - 12:43am
    As usual Paul Reynolds is "on the money"! I am afraid MALC that the UK propaganda machine has hijacked your worl (European) view. Check out...
  • User AvatarPaul Walter 22nd Feb - 11:39pm
    David It was a post by me, on behalf of the team. I happily stand by it. It’s an attractive PPB. I thought the narration...
  • User AvatarTynan 22nd Feb - 10:19pm
    @Mary Reid, whilst not specifically about gay marriage there is some evidence that suggests that opinions towards homosexuality in the capital differ to those of...
  • User AvatarRodney Watts 22nd Feb - 9:19pm
    @Miranda Pinch. An excellent comment on some flawed thinking, and so glad it came from a like- minded Jewish LD. Whilst we appreciate Lorenzo’s concern...
  • User AvatarRob Heale 22nd Feb - 9:14pm
    Social Liberals have supported the ideas of "co-determination" and "co-ownership" for decades. Lets hope that Liberal Democrats can develop these ideas to help give employees...
  • User AvatarDavid Becket 22nd Feb - 7:42pm
    Agreed Nigel. I am hoping for change and think it may be possible, but when a spokesperson for Voice approves of this video it shows...