NEW POLL: What do you think the next general election holds in store for the Lib Dems?

August may be a quiet month in domestic politics, but it’s merely the precursor to the new Parliamentary year to come – by the end of which there will have to be a general election, and (it seems almost certain) a change of government. What better time, then, to ponder what we think awaits the Lib Dems at that election?

Our poll ratings seem steady enough, consistently in the 18-20% range – down on the equivalent stage in the 2001-05 Parliament, when the party was boosted by its lone opposition to the Iraq war – but pretty strong compared to most other Parliaments. The unknowable next time round is how far the party can defend its seats aganst Tory challenges (and pick up a couple of surprise gains) while gaining ground on Labour.

Which brings us neatly to our new poll question: What do you think the next general election holds in store for the Lib Dems?

Here are your options:

  • An increase in % vote and an increase in seats;
  • An increase in % vote but a decrease in seats;
  • A decrease in % vote but an increase in seats;
  • A decrease in % vote and a decrease in seats.
  • The choice is yours. Feel free to show your working in the comments thread below.

    Read more by .
    This entry was posted in Voice polls.
    Advert

    17 Comments

    • I’d go for a decrease in vote but about the same number of seats – though whether they’ll be the same seats is arguable. I think we will lose a couple in the South West and possibly SW London too, but they could well be balanced by picking some up in the North of England.

    • I basically agreed with KL – if a GE was held today – with possibly an increase of up to 5-10 seats.We a have a pretty good record at holding seats & the Tories always try the ‘blue tide’ argument. I remember them saying Paddy days were numbered in 1990 in Yeovil!!!
      A GE next year – still all to play for us & Labour – I think the Tories have or are about to peak. With the increased spot light on what the Tories may do if they won will I think reduce their support (some people will begin to remember just how awful the Tories really are).

    • I think the markets have it right. Net loss of seats (10 – 15), just look at some of our paper-thin majorities. We’re too far behind in most Labour seats, and Tory tactical voting too ill-developed, to do better.

    • Lim Dem vote staying roughly the same but with a net loss of seats.

    • “possibly SW London too”

      On the basis of the Euro results and reccent by-elections things don’t seem to bad in South West London. We had our best ever Euro result in Sutton nearly beating the Tories and didn’t we win in Kingston and Richmond.

      In the Nonsuch by-elction the Tories did dreadfully which must bode well for both Pual Burstow and our excellent Lib Dem administration in Sutton.

    • Liberal Neil 7th Aug '09 - 4:44pm

      I think there is still a lot to play for.

      We have the potential to do well in the campaign itself if a) we make sure we have some simple hard hitting policies to campaign on and b) Nick comes across as well as he has the potential to do.

      I do think that Labour are unlikely to significantly improve their position, but I’m not convinced Cameron has sealed the deal either.

      Joe’s comment is also sound – in terms of the exact number of gains and losses a lot will come down to our local campaigns in the marginals.

    • I agree with Joe mostly. We should be bussing people down to the marginals over the next year. Doorstep engagement, keep it local.. and the Tories certainly don’t have a lock on the South West seats here.

      I also think that if there is a TV debate and Lab/Con don’t find a way of keeping Nick out of it, our vote share and number of seats could increase as a result of his performance, where he will no doubt come across as a strong leader with a manifesto that is most relevant to what this country is facing at the moment.

    • Stanley Theed 7th Aug '09 - 9:58pm

      I doubt very much if there will be a TV debate between the party leaders for the very reason that Labour and the Tories would wish to keep Nick out of it. Nothing would improve our chances of doing well more than if they were to attempt to do so. With parliamentary politics so despised by the most of the public, an agenda for real parliamentary reform would provide clear water from the other two parties who may attempt ‘light pruning’ rather than ‘root and branch’ reform. The chances are that we may lose a few seats and gain slightly fewer, but IF (a big if) we can gain the agenda in the next election we could do very well.

    • If the general election was tomorrow we would lose around 20 or more to the Tories, including one or more gained from Labour last time around. We would gain from Labour but not enough to stem the losses to the Tories – most of the 3 way marginals will go to the Tories. I would predict we’ll hover around the 50 mark.

      The great unknown is if Nick Clegg will be able to break through with the increased coverage given by the election campaign – this could give us the breathing space to make a difference in the marginals (or not).

      The one thing I would say is that (probably because of lack of resources) my perception is that we’re not fighting anywhere near the number of Labour seats we should be at the moment. The Tories have already shifted resources away from the ultra-marginals with Labour and are fighting more seats harder.

      In Yorkshire as far as I can tell we are still fighting the same 6 or so seats we were 18 months ago despite Labour’s vote having collapsed in that time. If this continues until the general election we are squandering an opportunity to make real gains amongst Labour voters – whether we gain actual seats this time or not – that could change the political landscape for a generation. If we can’t get the money/resources now when will we be able to?

    • Herbert Brown 8th Aug '09 - 11:08am

      I think a lot could depend on what happens during the campaign.

      I think it’s fair to say that Clegg has become more confident and polished in his media appearances, but I’m not so convinced by his grasp of detail. A couple of blunders of the kind we’ve seen previously could do a lot of damage.

      More importantly, given the strength of feeling against the government, I think the Tories will be pushing at every opportunity the idea that the Lib Dems could keep Labour in power. The number one priority should be for the party to come up with a clear answer to that accusation, which is acceptable to those who have previously voted Conservative, but have switched to the Lib Dems in previous years. If that line of attack can’t be effectively countered, I reckon losses to the Tories could be a lot heavier than some here are hoping.

    • I have been thinking about this since 2005 & the conclusions i came to then have been confirmed by my reading of events since, in GB percentages with changes since 2005, im predicting –
      Tory Labour LDs Others
      37%(+4) 26%(-10) 26(+3) 11%(+3)

      Trying to guess the seats is a mugs game, even if we had enough data from Wales & Scotland, there a number of models out there & they give wildly different results. The crucial points are that we have a real chance of beating Labour in vote share but not in the polls till the last days of the campaign, if then.

    • Roger Roberts 8th Aug '09 - 6:14pm

      Everything to play for ! I read of more activity (in many Welsh constituencies and over the border). If the Election is first Thursday in May 2010 -with 8 months to go we can break through more effectively than ever before. The massive leaps forward in seats over the past 3 elections defied all opposition forecasts. We mustn’t throw in the towel at this stage – that makes no sense at all ! I believe that the real success story of the next election could be ours.

    • Libdem Guru 9th Aug '09 - 4:55pm

      I agree with the last poster, but the policies are often too whimsical, and need real teeth, as do the front benches.
      I simply just don’t believe the current pr/comms team are up to much (even although they are from the likes of saatchi and saatchi). why do we have 12 in the pr team but rubbish pr!

    • @ Herbert Brown

      That point about the Tories running a strategy suggesting we would prop up a Labour government to keep the Tories out of power could be a tragically effective attack. Hopefully Cowley street are mulling a counter, if not.. =S

    One Trackback

    • […] our readers – who, I cannot emphasise enough, may or may not be Lib Dem supporters – what you think the next general election holds in store for the Lib Dems? Here’s what you told us: 24% (116 votes): An increase in % vote and an increase in seats 22% […]

    Post a Comment

    Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

    If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

    To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

    Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

    *
    *
    Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

    Advert



    Recent Comments

    • Peter Hirst
      Our government either does not understand the niceties of inter-governmental diplomacy or chooses to ignore them. Both are unfortunate when you are dependent on...
    • Katerina Porter
      The great fault is that "screening" is now done in Britain. It used to be done in the original country -in our consulate I think. Presumably this was changed ...
    • Peter Martin
      @ Joe, The r-g relationship was the main thing I remember from reading Piketty's book Capital. I can imagine Warren Mosler saying something like: "So what if...
    • Brad Barrows
      The crux of the issue is to get a clear answer to the question ‘whose responsibility is it to pay for the social care costs of (mainly) elderly people who are...
    • Matt Wardman
      @SimonR I'm not clear how you boost the flow through the same pipes without boosting the pressure. But I have not revisited my gas laws from O level for t...