One element missing from the Queen’s Speech was the Communications Data Bill, aka the ‘snoopers’ charter’. No surprise to Lib Dems: Nick Clegg torpedoed it last month.
So I had a momentary spasm of concern to see on ConservativeHome this story from Mark Wallace: The Snoopers’ Charter comes sneaking back. Again.
I asked Lib Dem MP Julian Huppert (who’s played a crucial role in safeguarding civil liberties this parliament, including on this Bill) if there were any truth in it, and got an immediate reply…
@stephentall @wallaceme it’s not coming back. At least this parliament.
— Julian Huppert (@julianhuppert) May 8, 2013
… and another from Lib Dem president Tim Farron:
@julianhuppert @stephentall @wallaceme Yes I concur. I saw Stephen’s tweet but thought I’d let Julian answer first. As it was directed 2 him
— Tim Farron (@timfarron) May 8, 2013
Here’s Mark Wallace’s reply:
Good to see @timfarron @julianhuppert affirming the Snooper’s Charter is dead for good – hopefully Home Office civil servants know that too
— Mark Wallace (@wallaceme) May 8, 2013
As Mark highlights, the Home Office has a track record of returning to the scene of its civil liberties crimes. Joanthan Calder made this point strongly over at his Liberal England blog a couple of weeks ago: Lib Dem snooper’s charter victory is great, but we must be vigilant: “… the danger has not gone away. The price of liberty is eternal vigilance, and all that.”
And of course Lib Dems have within our own ranks — in the person of Lord (Alex) Carlile — one of the most avid agitators for new powers to be given to the authorities (aka protecting our freedoms by giving them up). Here he is on the BBC’s Daily Politics again making his familiar case for the erosion of civil liberties in the name of the greater good.
* Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall.
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
The Absence of War: David Hare's fictionalised version of the 1992 general election
Burnham's betrayal on political funding
Sorry seems to be the hardest word
A day out at the football...
Listen to Dr Francis Young on the history of fairies
Neil Sandison
Carl Pierce
Christopher Burden
Mick Taylor
2 Comments
We all have our areas where we strongly disagree with the party mainstream view, but I have to question why Lord Carlile insists on making a stand on this issue against the party. There is no chance the party position will budge and I’m not sure what he is achieving other than making the party look split. Time for him to focus his energies on other issues in my view, and I hope the leadership will ‘encourage’ him in that direction.
Indeed, Charles Farr will not quit just because this government said no. He’ll be making the next government introduce the same damn thing again and we’ll have to fight it off again – all at considerable public expense.