Opinion: A life discarded

 

Mr K. had arrived on the wing at Brixton Prison on the Friday. By Monday morning he was dead. He had managed to hang himself using a sheet tied around the window bars. No-one knew what time he had died. It would be interesting to know whether the inquest showed up the notoriously lax attitude of Brixton night duty staff to night time cell checks.

No-one really remembered speaking to him and all anyone amongst the prisoners could really say was that he had arrived on Friday, was short and slight, had an Irish accent and kept himself to himself. He had stayed in his cell – one of the few on the wing for single occupancy – except for when he collected his food.

No doubt he had been asked the standard question on his arrival at Brixton. At reception he would have been asked by an officer, “Are you thinking of harming yourself?” Presumably he had replied “No”. A box on the receiving documentation would have been ticked and Mr K. would have been handed over to Healthcare. During the interview with the receiving nurse he would have been asked the same question and he presumably gave the same reply. An entry will have been made on the computer and Mr K. would have been on the way to the wing.

There is no psychological analysis. There would have been no interview scheduled with a trained clinical psychologist. Most members of the prison psychological services are trainee forensic psychologists whose primary role is to identify risks of re-offending and run offender training programmes. Whilst they do have a role in “assessing risk of suicide, self-harm or other high risk behaviour” – according to the job description – they are not available for receiving new prisoners.

They are also only available from 9 a.m to 5 p.m.. At night the role of dealing with prisoners in crisis is devolved to “Listeners” – prisoners who have been trained by the Samaritans.

Ministry of Justice figures released in January showed that there had been 82 suicides in prisons in England and Wales on 2014 – including Mr K. – a rise of 5% on the previous year and the highest level for seven years. Fourteen were between the ages of 18 and 24.

The Grayling cuts have put an ever greater strain on the prison service – on both officers and prisoners. Hours when cells are opened have been restricted by lack of staff. Prison overcrowding is increasing. Opportunities for effective training and rehabilitation are decreasing. The Psychological Services have no role in prison reception. It is a toxic mix.

Liberal Democrats have long said that prison is not the best place for many who are in there. Many have psychological problems. It is time to press for better analysis of risk to prisoners and for trained psychologists to be available to divert offenders to better alternatives to prison and to analyse risk and provide treatment in prison.

* Richard Edwards is a pseudonym for a contributor who wishes to remain anonymous

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

5 Comments

  • Prisoner K? Was that deliberate?

  • sally haynes-preece 7th Jul '15 - 7:12pm

    I do occasional work at HMP Birmingham. As far as I am aware all new inmates are seen by a member of the medical team. This has to happen because so many inmates have drug problems which may need medical intervention if only to ensure the inmate has access to medication to deal with withdrawal symptoms. This initial assessment does include questions about self harm. But as a therapist I know how hard it is to help someone who doesn’t want to be helped .

    There is a lot wrong in our prison service, and if we gave proper effective help to drug addicts the prison population would be much reduced.. (I won;t get on my soap box but I am also a pharmacist…..and I know how dire our current drug programmes are, and how ineffective the law is……but thats really a separate issues.) With my therapist head on I have to say this. Why ever this man was sent to prison tho we cannot assume he killed himself because he was imprisoned, or that he was capable of being helped. This may not be a failure of the prison service, but that does not mean changes don’t need to be made.

  • Nick Cotter 7th Jul '15 - 9:22pm

    As a criminal legal aid solicitor of 20+ yrs standing where cut after cut after cut has faced our “Industry” I will say deliberately provocatively – the system is in total meltdown and there are NO votes in Defending Criminals (Alleged).
    Most of the public just want “THEM” Locked Up.
    LASPO, Civil Legal Aid destruction, Ditto Crime,
    It is risible to suggest “OUR JUSTICE SYSTEM IS THE BEST IN THE WORLD”
    Sadly it is in Terminal Decline, and very few people care …………………….

  • Richard Underhill 7th Jul '15 - 9:39pm

    “The sentence known as life” needs to be explained because the Prison Service does not want riots and has a duty to work for rehabilitation. This would be difficult if a PM decided that she wanted a prisoner to serve whole life and may trigger an application to the ECtHR.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Neil Hickman
    The current World Cup, beside being a monumental exercise in chiselling, is a massive ego trip for one of the most unpleasant and dangerous individuals on the p...
  • Tom Bailey
    Thumbs up to this article. FWIW, I feel that something has changed in this Iran~US~Israel “debacle”, that will transform the region. Iran, in their Memora...
  • expats
    David Raw 14th Jun '26 - 1:14pm; David, Jack Priestley, obviously, never watched Millwall or Leeds Utd in the 1970's... I read ‘The Good Companions’ ...
  • David Raw
    I normally agree with Nonconformist and Expats on most things, but clearly they've never read up on that son of literature from Bradford, J.B. Priestley. Here's...
  • Tom Reeve
    I always feel smarter after reading one of your columns! Informative, polemical, pointed. Thank you. The biggest question we face as a society (after climat...