Opinion: Why Sir Cyril was wrong

Now, it’s easy to pretend that your political hero is perfect. It’s easy to write hagiographical accounts of a life without mistakes.

I felt that about the late Sir Cyril Smith MBE, formerly MP for Rochdale. I shall forever feel proud about how Cyril took me under his wing. I will be forever proud now that Sir Cyril called me his friend and gave me so many tips, so many words of advice about how to do my job. (I was Lib Dem Agent in Rochdale from 2004 – 2009) I wrote about ‘our Cyril’ for his 80th Birthday

Cyril shot from the hip – you see, unlike many of our elected politicians – he put his patch first! He didn’t care for party politics, it was all about Rochdale. Any MP, or would be MP would be make a point of studying his respect in his beloved Rochdale.

I met Cyril too late in his life – aged 79, the chance to meet this legend will stay with me forever. He was a mentor, always willing to elicit a wise word, he was a critic, always willing to have his say but more than all – he kept me in politics, because I believed we could change people’s lives… and so we did. Hundreds of times more than I did, I did my bit, don’t get me wrong – but talk to pensioners in his beloved home town and you’ll begin to realise why Cyril was so popular.

It was Cyril’s love of Rochdale that made him call for death penalty of Stefan Kiszko, accused of murdering Lesley Molseed, of Turf Hill just weeks before I was born in late 1975. In the light of national news ‘evidence’, Cyril called for the death penalty, citing the abhorrence of local Rochdale folk. His views were echoed by a vociferous local community – Cyril’s community! Stefan was innocent, after decades in prison he died soon after leaving. He’d received a ‘relative’ sentence. Cyril was wrong.

Now, I don’t blame Cyril or his brother Norman. I spoke to Cyril about it soon after – he was desperately sorry. He knew his reaction was out of order, he apologised to the family and he taught me a lesson. “Never get carried away with the media, take a minute before reacting to anything and…. don’t look after the patch ‘unemotionally’ Don’t blame Cyril!

Read more by or more about , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Dave Hennigan 4th Aug '11 - 4:29pm

    As I said Geoff, Sir Cyril was by no means perfect. When Stefan Kizsko was released from prison and found to be innocent, it made Cyril evaluate his opinion of the death penalty.

  • Granville Spencer 5th Aug '11 - 9:55pm

    The Stefan Kisko case and others should be enough to put most people off the death penalty.
    I remember Sir Cyril ; I can’t say I met him as such, but we counted money together at a fundraiser meeting.
    Around that time Harold Wilson had announced his retirement . When asked , by a TV reporter ,who he thought would be Labour’s new Leader, the then Mr. Smith, just said “Callaghan” and kept walking. Plain spoken to the point; an honest answer.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Little Jackie Paper
    Surely the ordoliberal consensus is a very big factor domestically for Germany. Whether exporting ordoliberalism via the single currency was a good idea...I'...
  • David Raw
    @ Paul : 6 December, 1923, 158 seats, 29.7%....
  • Joseph Bourke
    Peter Martin, Beveridge's paper on full employment (Full Employment in a Free Society) was published in 1945. He defined full employment as a state where th...
  • Marco
    @ Matt, NCFR I think the example Matt is looking for is when measles reached Pacific Islands such as Tahiti and around 20% of the population was lost. ht...
  • john oundle
    Martin ' The US will implacably oppose anything that might destabilise the Good Friday Agreement. ' That of course includes the new NI protocol....
Thu 11th Mar 2021