PMQs: Nadine Dorries leaves the PM speechless

There was a plethora of possible topics for Ed Miliband to raise at Prime Minister’s Questions today – Libya, the economy, phone hacking etc. In the event he chose two very strong issues.

First, he raised the subject of the postponement of the elections for police commissioners. This will cost £25 million, said Cameron. Ed Miliband said this is the “wrong priority for the country”, saying that £100 million plus is being “wasted” on elected politicians, which could pay for 2,000 extra police officers.

This was a very strong point, but sadly, as so often is the case, this was spoilt by reference to Labour’s record. As Cameron retorted, the last Labour government promised directly elected representatives to give people a say over policing.

Secondly, Ed Miliband picked on the NHS and scored a bit of a slam dunk. He asked Cameron to explain why waiting times for operations have gone up by 60%. David Cameron responded by saying that waiting times for outpatients have gone down. So, in other words, if you need a heart operation you have to wait longer. But that’s OK, because if you’ve stubbed your toe you’ll be sorted out in double quick time. It was a near-cretinous answer from Cameron.

It’s getting to the stage when the riot police need to be called into the House of Commons Chamber whenever Nadine Dorries (Con) gets up to speak. The Speaker had to intervene twice in her exchange with the PM. She complained about the influence of the LibDems and asked Cameron to tell Nick Clegg who’s boss. Cameron tried to answer this: “I know the honourable lady is extremely frustrated…” – he started. Amidst much roaring he said “I’ll start again”. Then, as the roars continued, he said “I’m going to have to give up on this one”.

Mark Reckless (Con) also raised a “LibDems have too much influence” question later. There is a definite hard core of Tory MPs who just don’t like what’s happening in the coalition.

Sir Alan Beith (LibDem) (who, in contrast, to Nadine Dorries was heard in complete silence) asked the PM to ensure that the banks will never again be bailed out because they are too big to fail. Cameron more or less agreed.

Simon Wright (LibDem) asked about the inequity of ending the 50% top tax rate. Interestingly, Cameron answered by enthusiastically praising a couple of the coalition government’s tax reforms which have helped the less well off, both advocated by the LibDems.

Paul Walter blogs at Liberal Burblings

Read more by or more about , , , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in News and PMQs.


  • Ruth Bright 7th Sep '11 - 5:31pm

    I believe in abortion on demand so I am not exactly a fully paid up member of the Nadine Dorries fan club, however I think she was treated appallingly during PMQs and the following debate on her amendment. There is no way a man talking passionately about an issue of conscience would have been treated that way.

  • Stuart Mitchell 7th Sep '11 - 8:13pm

    The BBC reports that the £25 million delay to the police elections is being imposed for the political convenience of the Lib Dems :-

    A few months ago the Lib Dems blew £100m in the failed quest to get an extra 30 MPs, now they are blowing £25m to protect a few Lib Dem councillors. Shameful.

  • Simon McGrath 7th Sep '11 - 9:58pm

    Offensive, sexist, patronising. Disgraceful comment from cameron.

  • I don;t particularly like Nadine Dorries but I do think some of the stuff that’s been said is verging on misogyny (apols if spelling wrong).

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • David Langshaw
    Just to add to the Singapore imagery, it's worth remembering that the Japanese advanced all the way down the Malayan peninsula on bicycles....
  • Geoff Reid
    In the midst of the alarms and excursions of an election campaign - and the necessary simplifications - it is very refreshing to be reminded of the ground on wh...
  • Bill Le Breton
    Fantastic piece. Thank you....
  • Neil Hickman
    Sadly, Martin, I fear you’re right. Labour apparatchiks would far rather a monopoly Labour government than one dependent on the Lib Dem’s (and kept honest ...
  • Martin Gray
    If Labour - as predicted win by a landslide I can't see a change in the voting system anytime soon. PCC and local elections have a poor turnout - no amount of a...