Tag Archives: magic money tree

LibLink: Vince Cable: Politicians get lost in search for fabled Magic Money Tree

Vince Cable has written for City AM about governemnt’s fiscal responsibilities and how it has become less important to be financially credible.

Yet since the 2015 election, belief in financial magic appears to have grown. Brexit’s biggest appeal was a treasure trove to finance the NHS. Labour has caught the new mood.

A few weeks ago, shadow chancellor John McDonnell added £200bn of PFI contracts to a lengthening list of Labour financial commitments, including the nationalisation of rail franchises, energy and water utilities, free universities, and much else.

The IFS was scathing at the June election about Labour’s numbers, but it did little political harm, perhaps because the Conservatives had no numbers at all, and have since oscillated between preaching austerity and signing cheques when pressed. My own party, the Liberal Democrats, received an IFS Gold Medal in 2017, but it did us little good.

He then goes on to talk about a recent discussion with economics students who thought that austerity had had its day. Vince recounts the main points that he made with his response:

Posted in LibLink | Also tagged , , and | 39 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Martin
    "Similarly, decentralisation in the UK is not really decentralisation. Until sub-national government can borrow against and raise local taxes which replace...
  • expats
    Tom Bailey 26th Jun '26 - 7:28am....The Manchester Evening News was part of the Burnham fan club, and so, never delved too deeply in Andy Burnham & his wife...
  • Peter Martin
    " Notwithstanding, there is no emphasis from Burnham on macroeconomic policy, but he does adhere to the concept of debt-financed Keynesian stimulae" ...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Roland, You could be right about the 28 turbine manufacturers. But my comment: ” but it does raise the question of why there is so little UK involve...
  • Tom Bailey
    The Manchester Evening News was part of the Burnham fan club, and so, never delved too deeply in Andy Burnham & his wife’s relationship with public funds....