Tag Archives: the union

Super Lib Dem Lords on Super Saturday: Jeremy Purvis on the potential break up of the UK

At the weekend, Lib Dem Lords basically tore apart Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal, highlighting its danger to our prosperity and to the very make up of our country. Jeremy Purvis highlighted the threat to our country.

For the first time in our union’s history, part of our union will be under the legislative authority of a foreign entity in which the people living in that area will have no representation. Part of our union will have the laws governing its economic policy and trade regulations set by a foreign entity whose rules they will have no say in. Taxes affecting businesses and consumers will be set by that foreign entity but their representatives will have no vote on them. To be clear: according to the schedules to the new backstop, 371 laws and regulations that would not apply to Great Britain would automatically be applied to Northern Ireland. On 1 October, the noble Lord, Lord Duncan, stated:

“Any deal on Brexit on 31 October must avoid the whole or just part—that is, Northern Ireland—being trapped in an arrangement where it is a rule taker”.—

That is what the Government propose today. The Conservative Party frequently lauds the fact that it is the Conservative and Unionist Party owing to its role in the defeat of Irish home rule, but it now puts in front of us a proposal for the UK to be one country with two systems. We can see elsewhere in the world how effective that is. Yesterday, this “one country, two systems” Brexit was hailed by the Foreign Secretary as terrific news for Northern Ireland because it will stay aligned with the EU. Presumably, he will now say that doing so is also open to Scotland.

The deal is utterly contrary to the Government’s position when they adopted the UK internal market framework, which this Parliament debated, and when they explicitly said that there would be no division within the four nations of the union. Given that it is also the opposite of what Boris Johnson presented to ​the DUP conference, when he said that this would never happen under a Conservative Government, there is little surprise that the lines in the sand have been washed away by waves of duplicity. As my noble friend Newby said, in January the noble Lord, Lord Callanan, stated:

“We will give an unequivocal commitment that that there will be no divergence in rules between … Great Britain and Northern Ireland”.—

The House can make its own mind up about where equivocation lies. Yesterday, the Home Secretary spoke doublespeak with alacrity on the BBC. She claimed that the deal takes back our laws—but not the 371 of them that apply to Northern Ireland and, therefore, the jurisdiction of the European court. She said that it takes back our borders— but it creates a new border between the nations of our island and, as the noble Lord, Lord Kerr, indicated, a new European Union border within the United Kingdom for the first time in our history. She said that it takes back control over our money—but we will be a tax collector for the EU, and the UK bodies in Northern Ireland will be forced to apply EU taxes that they have no role in determining.

Posted in News | Also tagged and | 7 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarPeter Hirst 15th Nov - 7:15pm
    How different our country will look with these new trees, all taking carbon out of the atmosphere, promoting biodiversity and creating new areas for recreational...
  • User AvatarPeter Hirst 15th Nov - 7:05pm
    When the electorate experiences our way of doing things, it likes what it sees.
  • User AvatarJayne Mansfield 15th Nov - 7:00pm
    @ Mick Taylor, I don't think I can talk to the Labour Party intransigent or otherwise, is still a broad church , not all members...
  • User AvatarRobert Heale 15th Nov - 6:49pm
    As a long-standing L/D Member who lives in Brighton Pavilion Constituency I would challenge some of the comments. If your M.P. has a higher degree...
  • User AvatarDavid Evans 15th Nov - 6:35pm
    I do wish that we would stop referring to Brexit uncertainty. All it does is reinforce the message people know best - Boris Johnson's solution...
  • User AvatarPeter Hirst 15th Nov - 6:33pm
    The climate will suffer if we leave the eu. Combating climate change needs money and we will have less of it. It is an indulgence...