Tag Archives: Tory

Working through the LabCon trick

We all know that the duopoly of Labour and Conservative parties is awful. We all know that this particular lot are awful. So again, the question arises: why are we, and other parties like the Greens, flat-lining in the polls?

I have a theory about part of the cause and a suggestion for what to do about it. It is that lovely thing, the UK’s dysfunctional electoral system. The system does not just attribute different values to different votes; it also distorts how people cast their votes. Voting for who you most want runs the risk of helping elect whom you least want.  First Past the Post not only accentuates this risk, it is such that the risk is far greater for parties outside the duopoly than for either member of that duopoly.

That puts non-duopoly parties in a fix.

Every time we attack the Conservatives we not only differentiate ourselves from the Conservatives but also Labour from Conservatives, and vice versa. We may offer a benefit to make the risk of voting for us worthwhile, but we also offer the same benefit, against a much lower risk, for voting Conservative/Labour. If we criticise the Conservatives, we bolster the “we must get rid of the Tories” narrative, and the lowest risk way of doing that is to vote Labour. If we attack Corbyn, we feed into the “stop Corbyn” narrative, and the lowest risk way of doing that is to vote Conservative. The duopoly maintains a system so arranged that anytime another party criticises either of the duopoly parties the electorate’s benefit in sticking with that duopoly increases.

It’s a LabCon trick.

Posted in News and Op-eds | Also tagged | 24 Comments

Huhne: Tory right wants UK to be semi-detached member of EU

Politicshome points us towards an interview in The Independent with Lib Dem Energy Secretary Chris Huhne, who warns that the Tory eurosceptic (or should that be europhobic) right wants nothing more than the UK to become ‘semi-detached’ from the EU.

Criticising the Tory right’s approach to the EU, he says:

I am worried there is a tendency on the Conservative right wing, a significant part of its parliamentary party, that does not appreciate the importance of being at the table in Brussels when it comes to negotiating the rules for the single market – and does not understand the strength

…

Posted in News | Also tagged , and | 5 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Paul Holmes
    Mick you say that the Liberal Democrats never polled anywhere near the 6M votes won by the Liberals in Feb 1974. You mean apart from the 5,999,606 in 1992, or t...
  • David Allen
    Burnham and Milburn are genuinely trying to tackle this problem. The Tories didn't. Starmer didn't. The Lib Dems seem to begrudge giving Burnham any credit. ...
  • Mick Taylor
    @PaulHolmes. Your unknown Liberal Party I joined in 1964 polled 6 million votes in February 1974. The electoral system prevented them making sweeping gains. The...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Thank you for an “other countries” article. Ditto the comment from P M. Might it be relevant that South Africa, France and Spain have Neoliberal policies...
  • Paul Holmes
    I can though very much agree with what you say about Clegg. But of course he, Laws, Alexander etc were very much classic Economic Liberals favouring lower taxe...