The 12 Op-Eds of Xmas (Day 7)

Throughout the festive season, LDV is offering our readers a load of repeats another chance to read the 12 most popular opinion articles which have appeared on the blog since 1st January, 20109. The sixth most-read LDV op-ed of 2010 was by a long-standing Lib Dem member who preferred, for professional reasons, to remain anonymous, and originally appeared on 22nd January …

Opinion: UK Border Agency plunges colleges into crisis

I wrote recently about the train-wreck that is happening before our eyes with the new student visa rules. Well, there has been a new development. The UK Border Agency has abruptly suspended the visa-sponsoring licences of more than 50 private colleges without giving reasons. All over the place, crisis talks are taking place in the colleges affected, as people try to work out what on earth is happening. Is this more of the deep-rooted incompetence that we have all come to expect from the Home Office, or has a political decision been taken to expel lots of dark faces and damn the consequences?

From where I sit, helping to administer a small college, it is hard to discern any rational basis for this action. Among the 50-plus colleges some are seriously dodgy, but the honest ones are utterly infuriated at being associated with the bad ones. Meanwhile, plenty of dodgy colleges still keep their licences. As ever, the UKBA is its inscrutable “don’t’ call us, we’ll call you” (or should that be “never explain, never apologise”?) self.

Let’s put this in practical, human terms. We have students whose visa renewals are due in ten days. What can they do? Look for another college that still has its licence and spaces available? Go back home with tail between legs and without the diplomas they came for? Or go underground for a while? These are serious, hard-working, intelligent students, not the black economy workers who so exercise the right-wing press. They have employers who really value them at their part-time jobs too.

Multiply that up across the country and there must be thousands of students in deep trouble. I hate to think how many court cases against the government are being hatched right now, especially in the colleges that specialise in teaching law. Students with months or years of visa still to run will carry on being taught properly, but inevitably they will worry. They know that mud sticks, and that the owners of this college instantly have less money to spend on library books, IT facilities, student welfare, and so on.

Despite what some people say (including Matthew H commenting on my last piece) many small colleges do a fine job of teaching, with small class sizes and without the useless but tenured staff that blight some universities. Our students are often poor, and in need of a lot of remedial English tuition, but they are not stupid, nor criminal, nor inclined to be terrorists. At least not now, but I cannot speak for how they will feel if they are utterly shafted by UK plc failing to deliver the decent education they were promised.

The root of the problem appears to be that the UKBA is still “not fit for purpose”. It does not have enough brainpower to behave rationally and is just lashing out like a wounded animal. Policing private colleges is actually quite an easy task. It is not as if colleges hide their existence. Just send round inspectors on unannounced visits to sit in on a couple of classes, talk to a few students, and sample a few college administrative records. That would rapidly identify which colleges need to be shut down, which are altogether different from the 50-plus who have (one hopes temporarily) lost their licences.

* Editor’s note on the author: this article was written by the head of a private college, who also authored this post and understandably prefers to remain anonymous. They are a long-standing Liberal Democrat member.

Read more by .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

One Comment

  • I’m sorry, but this is wholly unconvincing and the cynic in me wonders if it is in fact the author is the one doing the lashing out,

    1) ‘Among the 50-plus colleges some are seriously dodgy,’ This alone rather calls into question the strident tone here. As a % how many of these colleges are, ‘dodgy,’ and how many are, ‘seriously dodgy?’ Doesn’t this rather suggest that the UKBA are doing their job rather than seeking to visit misery on you? At least it sounds like you don’t wholly disagree with them/

    2) ‘Our students are often poor, and in need of a lot of remedial English tuition, but they are not stupid, nor criminal, nor inclined to be terrorists. At least not now, but I cannot speak for how they will feel if they are utterly shafted by UK plc failing to deliver the decent education they were promised.’ Promised by UK plc or promised by Colleges? The immigration system can not and indeed should not exist to prop up Colleges or to educate the world. As as to the suggestion that the refusal of a visa somehow makes people inclined to terror or somehow makes extremism, ‘legitimate’ – well that is a staggering assertion.

    3) ‘It does not have enough brainpower to behave rationally and is just lashing out like a wounded animal.’ So what you are saying is that any decision that goes against you is A Bad Thing. Anyone who disagrees with you is irrational – yes?

    4) ‘I hate to think how many court cases against the government are being hatched right now, especially in the colleges that specialise in teaching law.’ Yes, but these cases don’t exactly have a great success rate do they? The doctors, in a similar position, got an equality impact out of the courts. Nothing much else. I would hope that these promises and the lawyers who are surely rubbing their hands are not making promises.

    5) There seems to be this view amongst education institutions that they are somehow a special case. Go and try that line of reasoning with our Tory colleagues. In case you had not noticed the voters are not really big on students right now. Right or wrong, you can’t treat reality with contempt.

    6) ‘We have students whose visa renewals are due in ten days. What can they do? Look for another college that still has its licence and spaces available? Go back home with tail between legs and without the diplomas they came for? Or go underground for a while?’ I’m sorry, are you a College administrator suggesting people go underground? God I hope that the UKBA don’t see this.

    7) ‘has a political decision been taken to expel lots of dark faces and damn the consequences?’ Evidence? Or is this just a bit of talkboard play-to-the-gallery machismo?

    This might sound a bit unsympathetic. Maybe, but today I got a message from a British Embassy over in Eastern Europe. My wife’s brother had his visa application turned down today. I am not going to sit here saying it has flicked a switch in his head marked, ‘terror.’ I’m not going to say he is a special case or start saying people are thick or not fit for purpose. I’m going to work with the system set down by a Coalition government. My argument is with those chancers and visa overstayers as much as it is with the system. That you can say in one breath that some of these colleges are, ‘seriously dodgy,’ then in the next say that these seriously dodgy people are not a big peoblem for honest colleges and people like my brother in law is disingenuous to the point where I am struggling to take you seriously.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarSean Hyland 18th Dec - 1:22am
    Never been a fan of Farage. Guessing that he will, as he has always done, be certain to look after number 1 - himself.
  • User AvatarSean Hyland 18th Dec - 1:17am
    Peter Watson the article makes the same point about cherry picking polls whatever side of the debate you are on and the need to look...
  • User AvatarRoland 18th Dec - 1:04am
    @Sheila Gee - "Farage has served this country very well, and deserves his pension and retirement." Firstly, Farage and UKIP have not served this country...
  • User AvatarMartin 18th Dec - 12:41am
    Matt: What was leaves vision for the UK outside the EU? Do tell, because if it ever existed, it seems to have been completely forgotten....
  • User AvatarMichael BG 18th Dec - 12:33am
    @ Joe Bourke I don’t understand why you object to exempting those owner occupiers who have an income lower than the poverty level. I hate...
  • User AvatarMalcolm Todd 18th Dec - 12:17am
    Should be "notice to *quit*", obviously.