The Independent View: Broke Britain, not Broken Britain – have banks and the Government swindled the next generation?

Banks are jeopardising the prospects of the next generation, discouraging financial responsibility and leaving young people facing the sharp end of the credit crunch. With the Government, they have created a “gilded generation” of pampered and over-protected young people, mired in debt and unable to understand their finances.

The liberal free-market think-tank Reform’s new report, written in conjunction with the Chartered Insurance Institute and published this week, finds that the “IPOD generation” of 18-34 year olds – whom we have described as Insecure, Pressurised, Over-taxed and Debt-ridden – have been failed by the “financial establishment”.

Young people have grown up in a time of easy credit and high consumer expectations. Research by Populus, commissioned for the report, shows that they have substantial debts and minimal savings: the mean debt among 18-34 year olds is around £6,000, and 60 per cent have either no savings or less than £1,000. While the next generation have the ability and technological know-how to understand their position and take action, they are finding themselves hamstrung by an industry determined to service the old and patronise the young.

Banks and financial services are out of touch. They offer advice at a price beyond young people’s reach, and provide outdated products ill-suited to their flexible lives. Banks still focus on catering to a disappearing generation who set up home young and had jobs for life. This has created a lack of trust: our report finds that half of young people rely on friends and family as their main source of financial advice.

The situation is compounded by Government-sponsored regulation. So-called “consumer protection” policies are overprotecting young people into a state of irresponsibility, and heavy regulation of the financial services industry has pushed up the costs of financial advice.

Speaking at the launch of the paper, Julia Goldsworthy MP, Liberal Democrat Communities and Local Government Spokesperson, said that policymakers find it difficult to understand and respond to the “elusive generation”, but that there were things Government could do. An IPOD herself, she sympathised that regulation makes young people feel it is not important to understand financial products.

Ms Goldworthy also explained that it is important to look at regulation from the perspective of the consumer. Insisting on paragraphs of small print at the bottom of credit card bills is pointless if young people don’t understand how their debts actually mount up.

Young people know there is a problem, and they want to do something about it. They have been lulled into a false sense of security, growing up in a time of economic stability and historically low interest rates. The sharp shock of the credit crunch may have jolted them from their slumber, as they are challenged with burgeoning debt and a broken housing ladder.

The IPOD generation have a strong sense of responsibility and a desire to be in control of their finances – the explosion in the use of technology such as internet banking and price-comparison websites demonstrates a keenness to budget and manage their finances. But they are held back by a lack of financial literacy, the uninterested attitude of the financial services sector and excessive regulation.

Continuing this trend will result in a “generation of victims”, untrusting of Government and financial institutions, and lacking the capability to do anything about their predicament. There is an alternative: empowering young people to become a “generation of saviours”. This generation will take control of their own finances. They will demand new products from a reformed financial services industry, and will harness the freedom and information provided by Government to stimulate the economy and create innovative solutions to the crisis.

To save the next generation, Government and the financial services industry must help young people take responsibility and become financially capable.

* Dale Bassett is new media politics executive at Reform. The Reform-CII report Money’s too tight to mention: will the IPOD generation ever trust financial services? is available at Reform’s website, www.reform.co.uk.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds and The Independent View.
Advert

4 Comments

  • Andrew Tennant 22nd Oct '08 - 5:25pm

    My initial reaction to this piece was to feel somewhat belittled and patronised; though in the age bracket described I don’t feel a victim of the system and have the sense and upbringing to avoid debt (except for student loans) and to put a modest bit away from my (regrettably) modest income. My second reaction was to agree entirely with what Alix said; as ever the voice of reason – bring on the crash!

  • David Allen 22nd Oct '08 - 6:18pm

    The crash will help the IPOD generation, but we all need to recognise more of the “push factors” which have encouraged debt. Tuition fees have helped to persuade graduates that debt is normal, unavoidable, and stigma-free. Andrew Tennant may have had the “upbringing to avoid debt”, but the capitalist world has been working very hard to try to re-educate him! When George W Bush told Americans that the most patriotic thing they could do in response to 9/11 was to keep shopping, he was making the same point.

    Debt has driven the consumer boom. We have an advertising industry dedicated to inflating our perceptions of need, linked to a financial industry which has frantically worked to find ways we can all increase our private spending.

    The threat, if we do not sustain ever-increasing private spending levels, is business failure and mass unemployment. The threat, if we do sustain our current levels of consumption, is the exhaustion of the Earth’s resources.

    It is easier to see the need for change than to find a practical way to achieve it. But the debt crisis could prove to be a golden opportunity in disguise.

    We have woken up with a staggering financial hangover, after a long, hard party of conspicuous consumption. Reflation, Keynesian economics, and calls for lower taxes sound suspiciously like hair-of-the-dog remedies. Can anyone find a better, greener cure?

  • David – with you absolutely on that.

    Re. Dales call for reform of the financial services ‘industry’ – please reform it into the ground.
    We need real green industry building a sustainable future and making the earth a place we can all live without destroying it please, not these financial parasites. Mortgages and savings OK – the rest of the froth NO.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • John Grout
    This is a good start, but the sooner Ed corrects his statement about the Supreme Court judgement himself, the better. Hopefully he'll take the opportunity to do...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Mark, The rail network was only in private hands for the privatisation of British Rail in 1994 up until 2001. The Hatfield crash, which was blamed squarely...
  • Jennie
    Thank you, CJ. And thanks for the EDM too (and to every other MP who has signed it)...
  • Jenny Barnes
    David Evans “In workplaces and services that are open to the public: – trans women (biological men) should not be permitted to use the women’s facilities...
  • Mark
    Mick Taylor states that British Rail had an "enviable safety record." The idea that the railways were safer in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s or 1980s than they are...