Salmond promises childcare revolution after turning down Rennie’s plans for nursery education

Scotland’s First Minister Alex Salmond  gave his keynote speech to SNP Conference this afternoon. There were three things in it that struck me as a Liberal Democrat.

A numbers game

Apparently a “yes” vote for independence would be a vote for a “prosperous economy and a just society.” Does this remind you of any phrase being used rather a lot at the moment by any Liberal Democrat who can be persuaded to do so? I wonder how prosperous an economy built on wildly optimistic estimates of oil revenues would be to start with.

Many nationalists have been complaining about their fixed budget doesn’t give them enough control. Come 2015, they’ll have much more power to change that thanks to the Scotland Act introduced by Liberal Democrat Secretary of State Michael Moore. As he’s always said, that’s a stepping stone and there’s a growing consensus for further devolution in the future.

Power to the people?

It is said that to govern is to choose but even more fundamental than that is to choose how you are governed.

I did wonder if he was having a laugh, here, as his SNP Government will centralise anything that sits still for a minute or more. Schools, police, you name it. They have taken power from the people to Holyrood and they don’t get the idea of local communities having a say on things which affect them. As a highlander, I instinctively find the idea of a centralising SNP Government in Edinburgh as unpleasant as a centralising government in London.

People should not vote for independence thinking they will have more say. They won’t if the SNP have their way. However Ming Campbell set out a blueprint for giving more powers away from Holyrood in his Home and community rule commission report.

Transforming childcare

Salmond knows fine that women are more sceptical about independence and he has to win them over somehow. So it’s hardly surprising that he talked about childcare and even used the phrase the gender gap. Look what he had to say:

But I believe a transformational shift towards childcare should be one of the first tasks of an independent Scotland.

What a cheek! This comes only weeks after he turned down Willie Rennie’s pleas for more nursery education for 2 year olds. He already has powers to do something about this, but chooses not to. It’s a cynical move, especially given that Nick Clegg and Jo Swinson are in the process of implementing a radically different system of shared parental leave and are offering help with childcare costs to the tune of £1200 per child per year.

Voters in Scotland will have to choose between the reality of what is available to them and some unspecified revolution yet to come.

Willie Rennie noticed the same thing and said:

The First Minister’s decision to put childcare into his list of independence promises for tomorrow is not the outcome 50,000 two year olds who will grow up in Scotland between now and the referendum deserve. I’m disappointed that our reasonable and costed plans to deliver free nursery care for forty percent of two year olds is now being used as a sweetener in the independence referendum.

However I’m sure that parents, mothers in particular, will be even more disappointed. I want to build a stronger economy in a fairer society which enables every person to get on in life. It could not be clearer, or more saddening, that the First Minister is now confusing our nation’s ambition with his obsession for independence.

If I had to summarise the speech in a tweet, it would be “Iraq bad, Westminster evil, and we’re not going to give you goodies until you vote yes.” It was, as ever light on detail.

The other big news elsewhere from Inverness was a challenge to David Cameron to come and debate Salmond. The SNP know they don’t have the arguments, but if they can get an unpopular Tory PM an hour and a half’s airtime, they think that will scare voters into the arms of the Yes Campaign. The pro-independence arguments are so weak that even Cameron could demolish them, but Salmond’s challenge reveals more about the desperate situation of the Yes campaign.

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • I’m sorry to be rude, but the overkill of scottish issues on this website is just getting too much, Don’t get me wrong, the referendum is a huge deal, but the ratio of scottish stories compared to UK stories has been getting ridiculous.

    Nonetheless, I appreciate hearing scottish lib dem updates.

  • David Wilkinson 24th Mar '13 - 7:55am

    Whilst I don’t always agreed on the points made by Caron or LDV , I do like the postings from north of the border on Scottish issues and it is not over the top compared to the rest of the articles on LDV.

  • Caron Lindsay Caron Lindsay 24th Mar '13 - 9:48am

    Thanks, Ian and David. There have been a lot of Scottish stories this week, mainly because it was Scottish Conference last weekend. I think it’s important that LDV tries to cover as much as we can from all around the country. I’d really like to have more regular stuff from Wales, for example.

    Nobody is going to be interested in every article posted on any site. I don’t read every single article in newspapers. I don’t watch every programme on a tv channel. There are some people who are interested in Scottish stuff and we’ll continue to provide as much coverage as we can.

    Hannah, what would you like to see us do more of?

  • I believe this is one of the larger issues surrounding the referendum, that is not discussed enough. There is no doubt that Alex Salmond and the SNP are centralizing their political strategy far too much but we can not assume that the SNP will be in power for the rest of our lives. There will definitely be more opportunities for the Lib Dems than as the UK currently and just because Nick Clegg and his westminster party say no to independance that should not mean that Scottish Liberal Democrats should have to follow suit unquestionably. I believe the Lib Dems are a very scottish party (excluding Glasgow and the central west.)

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarMichael BG 4th Aug - 8:52pm
    Laurence Cox, In the Duncan Brack LDV article, Duncan sets out the terms of reference: • “Seek views on the conduct of the autumn...
  • User Avatarjayne Mansfield 4th Aug - 8:51pm
    I have no objection to people making choices as to whether they eat healthy or unhealthy food, providing of course they take personal responsibility for...
  • User AvatarKatharine Pindar 4th Aug - 8:50pm
    Gordon, I used to believe in the supremacy of Conference, but not any more since it was managed and misled at Bournemouth. No, give me...
  • User AvatarMarco 4th Aug - 8:43pm
    @Michael1 "The reason for the beeb is the same as that u am compelled to pay for the public library despite never borrowing a mills...
  • User AvatarNigel Jones 4th Aug - 8:39pm
    I agree with Michael 1. Many people over 75 can afford the fee and the only other way of funding the BBC would be through...
  • User AvatarMarco 4th Aug - 8:18pm
    @Phil Beesley "Have you ever run a jumble sale? Or are you making stuff up on the fly?" Haha probably the latter to be be...