A bit of a howler in the Tories’ press lines…

Sky News have managed to get hold of a Tory briefing document which gives its MPs and media spokespeople the messages they want to emerge from their Conference. It was drawn up in the wake of the Reckless defection and Newmark resignation. Things drawn up in haste can often cause more problems than they resolve and this is no exception. Take, for example, the bit where they say that they are not stating red lines in coalition negotiations before, er, stating one:

Q. Is policy X a red line for future coalition negotiations?

A. We’re not going to answer hypothetical questions about red lines for coalition negotiations. Our aim is to win an outright majority at the next election so we secure a better future for Britain and that’s what we’re working towards.

Q. But what about your Europe referendum? You’ve said that’s a red line?

A. As our commitment to have a referendum would have to be fulfilled by a specific date after the next election, we think it is right in this one instance to confirm it’s a red line.

For me the most amusing thing was this, in their list of achievements:

We’ve taken 3 million of the lowest paid out of income tax altogether

Now, whose idea was that? Not the Tories’, that’s for sure. In fact, at around 1 hour 18 minutes in, we have David Cameron explicitly tell Nick Clegg that the Liberal Democrat policy of raising the tax threshold wasn’t affordable:

They wanted to cut taxes for rich, dead people -and, given Osborne’s announcements at the Conservative Party conference yesterday, plus ça change. We wanted to cut taxes for ordinary working people and have over-delivered on that one.

And, as exhibit B, the front page of the Liberal Democrat manifesto:

Four key Lib Dem manifesto commitments

And it’s not as if the Tories embraced the idea in Coalition. As Nick Clegg said in March, he had to drag them kicking and screaming to do it at every single budget:

I – how can I – I’ll try and be polite on this. My Coalition partners, by contrast, have been spectacularly inconsistent. Beginning of the Parliament they were first going on about inheritance tax cuts for millionaires. Then they wanted to fiddle around with the upper rate of income tax. Then they wanted to fiddle around with the taxes for married couples. Then they wanted to fiddle around with taxes to give incentives to people to give up their employment rights to take up shares.

So they’ve got a fair amount of brass neck to now claim that somehow all they ever wanted all along was to see the allowance go up, because that’s not what they said in public, and crucially, it’s not what – actually what they said in private, either. I’ve had to drag the Conservative party, kicking and screaming, in every single budget negotiation.

We need to get in their face when they do stuff like this. David Cameron has also been trying to take credit for our Steve Webb’s Pensions Triple Lock on the Today programme.

What’s the antidote to this? I can’t think of a better one than talking to voters and telling them what we’ve brought to the Government. Our survival depends on it.

I have said many, many times before that we also need to give people positive reasons to vote for us, to show how we have put our anti-establishment, breaking down of barriers values of freedom and opportunity into practice in government. We’ve done lots of that from changing attitudes to mental health to giving extra money to disadvantaged kids in school to expanding childcare.

That positive message is very important, but we also need to remember that all those things about the Tory conference that turn our stomachs, from welfare to civil liberties, would be being implemented right now if it weren’t for us. That’s the reality of the Tories governing alone. I really hope it doesn’t take a spell of the Tories with an overall majority to show how much the Liberal Democrats did to hold them back.



* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , , , , or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Well-identified Caron. I am sure you were not alone in Lb Dems noticing this. I wonder how many of them just shrugged with despair? The new slimline Caeser Osborne also delivered this claim in his conference speech without having to remember or blinking at his autocue.

    Now tell me which of our Coalition Ministers is going to publicly and repeatedly confront the irTory ‘partners’ (sic) – and the public/media – with the fact that they are disgraceful dishonest credit-stealers?

  • Tony Rowan-Wicks 1st Oct '14 - 9:00am

    Well spotted Caron. And in reply to Tony, I would hope that every Lib Dem MP and every LD election campaigner is just waiting for the signal to “break out” from under the agreements and protocols of government. Get the time right as well as the message and our distinctive brand will be seen clearly once more.

  • richard boyd 1st Oct '14 - 7:45pm

    If the Tory PR machine can get their line into every national newspaper, what can the LD’s do>

    Perhaps go to the underbelly of news and flood Twitter and other social media with our story?

    I suspect more people 35-45 are on Facebook/Twitter than read the red tops.

    Richard Boyd

  • David Pollard 3rd Oct '14 - 12:56pm

    It is very flattering to have your policies adopted by another political party.

  • Robert Wootton 5th Oct '14 - 11:26pm

    I have just tweeted and liked this article on FB.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarJohn Marriott 20th Oct - 1:13pm
    @Nigel Jones The reasons to remain and why a hard Brexit would harm us were repeated ad nauseam in the run up to the 2016...
  • User AvatarArnold Kiel 20th Oct - 1:12pm
    Time to revisit the numbers: Since the referendum, the UK's economy has lost GBP 60 Billion of GDP, representing a 0,5% GDP-underperformance p.a. compared to...
  • User AvatarNigel Jones 20th Oct - 12:49pm
    We have not been explaining to people why we should remain or why a hard Brexit will harm our country, I said this in a...
  • User AvatarDavid Becket 20th Oct - 12:24pm
    @Martin Up to now she has done well, but we are heading into a dangerous phase and we need to move on and positively promote...
  • User AvatarBarry Lofty 20th Oct - 12:21pm
    Let's be honest every Tory government from John Major onwards has always looked over its shoulder at the far right of their party any middle...
  • User AvatarMartin 20th Oct - 12:13pm
    It is comforting to see David Becket revert to his accustomed role of decrying the leadership. My only question to him is 'What took you...