A graph, a dip, a policy: why the nursery premium is so important

Liberal Democrat conference in Brighton saw the a motion passed calling for the party to investigate the practicalities of introducing a ‘nursery premium’. At first glance this sounds like an obvious extension of the party’s existing pupil premium policy. Delving more closely into the data, however, shows that it is more than simply an obvious extension; it’s necessary to remove what is a bizarre anomaly arising from how other policies fit together.

Here is the extra assistance which is given for the education of children from the most deprived backgrounds in England for each age band from 1 year-old to 18 years-old:

Note that dip for 3 and 4 year-olds. It’s not as if politicians or teachers think those years are unimportant. Far from it; there is increasing emphasis on just how important people’s early years are for their later lives. Yet the combination of different policies to give extra help produce a rather weirdly overall impact as if ages 3 and 4 are much less important than 2 and not nearly as important as 5.

Hence the nursery premium – to plug that two-year dip which occurs at two of the most important years in people’s lives when it comes to shaping their future prospects.

So here’s to hoping those investigating the practicalities of a nursery premium come back with a plan that works.

Sources of data: For 2 year-olds, figures based on 2014/15 data as 2012/13 figures based on scheme details that are being changed and 2013/14 figures includes one-off capital provisions to increase capacity in the system; for 3-4 year-olds, figures based on National Audit Office data on the highest levels of extra provision in 24 pathfinder authorities in 2010/11; for 5-15 year-olds, figures based on latest announcement from David Laws; for 16-18 year-olds, figures based on the highest levels of extra provision in 2011/12. Thanks to Barnado’s for providing the data from which I have selected these figures.

* Mark Pack is Party President and is the editor of Liberal Democrat Newswire.

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Peter Watson 2nd Oct '12 - 4:09pm

    A few questions for clarification of the data presented in this chart:
    1. What is meant by “extra assistance”?
    2. Does the data for 3-4 year olds include free nursery place entitlement or is it “extra” to that?
    3. What is the £2900 that is paid for 2 year olds? On the face of it, that is more than enough to smooth over the dip for the next two years.

  • I was concerned to read recently in the Guardian, that this is not new or extra money, but is being topsliced from what was intended for Surestart .

  • @Margaret you may well have a point. My own Authority chopped £6M out of sure start. It is a Tory Authority which was enabled to take full advantage of the removal, by OUR govermnment of the ring fence around Sure Start grant. Strangely this was never mentioned at our selfcongratulatory Conference.

  • Ruth Bright 5th Oct '12 - 4:02pm

    I was going to ask the same question as Peter Watson surely the “dip” at 3 and 4 just reflects the excellent amount of universal provision at that point – it would be interesting to know more about the figures.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Andy Daer
    For some voters, breaking international law is reaffirmation that Britain has become Great again, because Brexit was about getting free from the tyranny of our ...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Might the provision of decent public services after World War 2 have been made possible by factors additional to socio-economic theory and the high likelihood ...
  • Martin Gray
    Despite the recent by-election victory - the polls still have the cons on mid thirties, with everything that's gone on ...Come the GE there won't be any stay at...
  • Roland
    Picking up the other thread in this case ie. the legal arguments being used to justify the decision, it is worth reading the full syllabus and opinion: https://...
  • William Francis
    Maybe, and me out on this... we call on the government and the train companies to offer an above-inflation pay rise to the rail workers, and then the strike wil...