It’s been a hell of a couple of weeks for exam students. Highers and A level results play a huge role in determining the course of your life. If you don’t get the grades you need to fulfil your aspirations, you have to rethink your whole life. And you will carry those grades around for your whole life.
The question of whether we should have a system that puts so much stress on our young people is up for debate, but that’s for another day.
We know, though, that there are clear differences between the nations of the UK. In Scotland and England, the whole thing has been a disaster. However, in Wales, our Kirsty Williams has presided over a system that she argues has credibility because it guarantees that AS level results from last year will be the minimum grade for this year. That is a system that was scrapped by one Michael Gove in England.
Watch her statement about the way the results have been calculated:
Watch this interview she gave ahead of the announcement of the grades:
Listen to Kirsty talk to Andrew Castle on LBC here.
Because we have maintained a system whereby AS-levels forms a significant proportion of a final A-level grade, we were able to us that in the moderation process and able to put in a safety net for students so they could not drop below their previous AS Level grade.
“The ability to do that has been very helpful, because those were exams which were set, taken in the same conditions and were externally assessed.
“That can give students, universities and employers real confidence in them”.
She also cast doubt on the validity of giving grades based on mock exams,
“Some schools don’t do mock examinations,” Ms Williams explained.
“Some use mock examinations as a way to boost confidence and deliver them in a way that perhaps they are there to encourage people.
“Other schools use them as a tool of encouragement in the other way, they will mark them really hard so that people don’t get complacent.
“Each school has a different approach which we believe is right for them.”
The Welsh Lib Dems had some clear messaging about results: