An extraordinary case was concluded in the election court in Birmingham last month in which a former Labour Lord Mayor of Birmingham was given leave by the Election Court to withdraw an election petition seeking to overturn his loss at the May 2022 elections to two Lib Dem Councillors.
The background is that in the election Labour’s Muhammed Afzal and a colleague were defeated by Lib Dem Cllrs – Ayoub Khan and Mumtaz Hussain – the relevant bit of the result was:
Ayoub Khan (Liberal Democrat) 3012 votes
Mumtaz Hussain (Liberal Democrat) 2542 votes
Muhammad Afzal (Labour) 2463 votes
Nagina Kauser (Labour) 2223 votes
During the election the Lib Dem candidates had said that Mr Afzal had been ‘treating’ voters – by giving out packets of dates with a Labour sticker on while canvassing. Cllr Khan had said on his Facebook page
Such is Labour’s desperation in the Aston Ward…that the current sitting councillor has decided to bribe the people of Aston for votes by giving them a special treat. They ought to know better…this is not Pakistan where you can buy votes.
The election petition said that this claim was false and intended to defame Mr Afzal’s personal character and that therefore the result of the election should be overturned.
This was clearly a very serious allegation: apart from losing their hard won council seats, losing the petition would make the 2 Lib Dem councillors responsible for heavy costs putting their homes at risk, possible criminal charges and and as Cllr Khan is a barrister it may have had very serious consequences for his career.