Author Archives: A retired medical doctor

The civil service impact statement for the Assisted Dying Bill could be very inaccurate

By A retired medical doctor | Wed 18th June 2025 - 5:31 pm

Editor’s note: This article contains details of terminal medical procedures which some readers may find upsetting.

The Civil Service has done an ‘impact assessment’ for what the NHS and hospice sector will look like if Kim Leadbeater’s assisted dying (AD) Bill becomes law.

It’s chosen a sample of a  few ‘comparator’ US jurisdictions  and New Zealand to show how many cases of AD there are (expressed as percentage  of total deaths). The population of the sample is equivalent to England and Wales.

The projection estimates a few hundred AD cases here a year initially, rising annually. However, New Zealand, in its first year of AD, recorded an AD rate six times the rate that was recorded in the first year in  California – equivalent to 4,000 England/Wales deaths if we scale up for population size. The maximum Civil Service estimate for the first year in England and Wales is 1,600 deaths. So what has gone wrong ?

Continue reading »
Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 13 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • David Allen
    The case for higher taxes is blatantly clear, unless you are a politician seeking votes. Everything in Britain - the NHS, the courts, the prisons, defence, and...
  • FS People
    @ Mick Taylor “The whole thrust of our complex and bewildering tax code IS to protect the rich. ” But it is not. We actually tax high earners more as a pr...
  • FS People
    The defences of the triple lock are just bizarre. @Mick Taylor “You propose making that worse by stopping uprating pensions.” That is not what was sai...
  • Pawel Urbanski
    I agree that capacity is the problem, but I think we might be fixing the wrong end of it first. Right now thousands of affordable homes are going up under pl...
  • Jana
    My memory of being brought up in a council house was that ordinary working people lived in council houses and wealthy people lived in private houses. Today, the...