Author Archives: David Gracie

David Gracie

Scottish Independence

By David Gracie | Wed 10th March 2021 - 9:15 am

English nationalists made us vote blind on Brexit.  Our eyes are now well and truly open. The SNP ask us to vote blind on independence in May.  They offer no plan.  They can’t. For the foreseeable future, leaving the Union would be a disaster for the Scottish people.

Scottish Government figures for 2019/20 expenditure and revenue show a deficit of 8.6%, about average for the last five years.  Our expenditure per head at £1,633 was about 12% more than the UK, and we paid £380 or 2.5% less tax, including oil and gas.  The rest of the UK envy our free university education, prescriptions and home care.  UK subsidies by the Barnett formula underwrite our jobs, health, pensions, education, social security and other public services.  According to the 2018 SNP Commission, an independent Scotland would need 5 to 10 years of austerity to replace them.

Continue reading »
Posted in Op-eds | Tagged and | 17 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Wrigley
    Surely our defining issue must be the the preservation, improvement and extension of Liberal Democracy in this country and beyond. By all means support it with...
  • Chris Cory
    Community politics should not be a technique for winning elections. It should be about the redistribution of power to local people. It is not about all the thi...
  • Jana
    Burnham plans a National Care Service for England and electoral reform for the UK. So what makes us distinctive for General Election 2029?...
  • David Warren
    We have been far too cautious for far too long. A bit like Thomas Tuchel in the last half hour of that World Cup semi-final against Argentina. I fear that l...
  • Jana
    I agree with this but would add something I believe important: we need to address the idea that those seeking ‘a place of safety’ should be allowed to pass ...