Author Archives: Laurence Mann

We need to seize this moment

It’s been a bruising and disappointing few days for all of us, but two nights’ sleep, a lot of conversations and some thought have left me impelled to express an opinion in the Voice. I am setting out my contentions, for which I am grateful to the many people I have discussed them with, below.

The first point is that the proposal to leave the EU is a major constitutional change and that it is just not apposite to make such changes on the basis of a simple majority in a referendum.

That point is reinforced by the fact that this referendum was agreed on the basis that it was an advisory referendum, not a mandatory one. I suspect that had anyone asked the question. “Why was there no threshold for the decision to be acted upon?”, the answer would have been to reiterate that the referendum was advisory and it was for Parliament to consider it.

The second point follows from that. Parliament should consider it. As such the fatalistic acceptance of the result as if it were a final judgement from an all-powerful deity is not an appropriate course of action for our legislative representatives. So this means that people should insist that such consideration takes place. There is a case for the proposition that the invocation of Article 50 without such consideration is illegal.

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 29 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • expats
    Did Ed have conference approval for his 'announcement' about supporting the opening of the 'Jackdaw' gas field and for an immediate '10p-a-litre cut to fuel du...
  • Jack
    It will take the Telegraph 5 minutes to claim that we are advocating closer EU alignment in order to help the already comfortable. Doesn't matter that it's not ...
  • Tristan Ward
    @ David Allen "This is a party for the comfortably off who demand to be more comfortably off." No it isn't. We are a party that wants to deliver freedom ...
  • Nonconformistradical
    "Fuel-duty cuts are also poorly targeted. The more fuel you use, the more you save, so someone driving a large, inefficient SUV gains more than someone in a sma...
  • Nick Baird
    I find myself disagreeing with most of Ed's ad-hoc policy announcements (including nukes, defence bonds, fuel tax cuts) which rarely stand up to scrutiny becaus...