BBC Question Time: open thread

After Paddy last week, it’s the turn of another former Liberal Democrat leader, Ming Campbell, to represent the party on the panel on tonight’s Question Time (broadcast on BBC1 and online from 10.35 pm GMT).

The panel will also include the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (and future Labour leadership contender?) James Purnell, senior Conservative politician Lord Heseltine, “well-known television personality” (aka the smuggest man in the world) Piers Morgan and novelist and journalist Rachel Johnson.

If you’re watching, and want to sound-off, please feel free to use the comments thread.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Lib Dem TV.


  • Andrew Duffield 8th May '08 - 10:53pm

    Ming and now Morgan both asserting that the credit crunch may have “bottomed out”. Grossly wishful thinking methinks. We ain’t seen nothing yet!

  • Is Rachel Johnson Boris’s sister? If so it seems that the BBC have once again effectively got 2 tories on the panel 🙁

  • Not about QT, but I just wanted to ask when the LDV online poll is going to be changed. You could leave the current one up there for 1,000 years and I doubt it’s going to change much.

  • Peter1919 – have you seen the poll in The Sun? Two Tories is probably fair representation!!!

  • Why would I have read the rubbish that is ‘The Sun’?

  • You wont need to read it there…it will be all over the other newspapers too….it has Labour on 23% Tories on 49% and us on 17%.

  • Haven’t looked but I bet it is a rubbish YouGov poll

  • Nice to see most of the panel talking some sense on the reclassification of cannabis, shame the government doesn’t

  • Make that 2 tories and two labour.
    BTW Things must be getting desperate for the gov when Piers Morgan is toeing the party line rather than kicking them.

    And as for James Purnell – he will go far : press the buttons and he speaks the message exactly as programmed – Not a nuance of doubt or apology.

  • It is YouGov poll but it will set hearts-a-flutter because people will see it as another indicator of which way the wind is blowing….

  • Passing Tory 9th May '08 - 10:10am

    Chris, YouGov seem to be rather more accurate than all those polls that said that Ken was going to squeeze victory in London. I suppose you can play the ostrich / PM and pretend everything is fine but I don’t think it is going to do yo9u much good int he long run.

    Indeed, given the horrendous Gordon and Wendy Show last week it is incredible that even 23% think that Labour is fit to govern, really.

  • Passing Tory, David Cameron has one very slight problem: his inability to take votes from Liberal Democrats. Even in Harlow (about which the blues crowed so loudly) all Lord Ashcroft’s horses and all Lord Ashcroft’s men couldn’t stop the Lib Dems beating them. Cameron is benefiting from an anti-Labour protest vote which will evaporate once the economy turns the corner and Brown gets his act together.

    Wow! Didn’t Lord Heseltine just fall into the trap when he started prating on about recreational drugs! The smirking Piers Morgan was only too happy to pull the lever on him.

  • Passing Tory 9th May '08 - 10:57am


    We have been through all this before, so we should probably just be content to disagree on this point.

    If you want to think that the Lib Dems are in a really strong position and want to jump up and down shouting it then go ahead. I still think that, on current positioning, the Lib Dems are likely to be squeezed come the next GE. This, I should add, is an academic opinion, rather than what I would like to see / what would be convenient for me to see / party spin etc.

  • Passing, if your opinion is, as you claim, objective, then presumably you have some facts to back it up?

    Ah, I get it. Of those millions of voters insanely in love with Cameron there is a significant minority who cannot tell the difference between a bird and a torch. And there are more of these Tories in areas where the Lib Dems are strong because they are so used to seeing birds on a daily basis.

  • Has anybody considered the possibility that the party that will get squeezed is Labour?

  • Passing Tory 9th May '08 - 11:26am

    Sesenco, of course I do. The question is, do you?

  • Passing, you know perfectly well I do, because, unlike you, I have presented them.

  • Dominic Haney 9th May '08 - 12:07pm

    Who is that Rachel Johnson? She did the rather embarassing thing of saying “As a Johnson…..”, as if we’re supposed to know who she is or what that means!

  • Grammar Police 9th May '08 - 12:11pm

    Come on then, mr virtually live-in Tory, what are your facts?

  • Thanks for asking me to suggest a new topic. Sadly I am only just checking in again after last night and there’s a new one up there already. I do admire the independence of mind of the person who voted that the next election will produce a big Labour majority. As a liberal I do like people who kick against the consensus.

    I thought Ming was very good last night. I was with him (and Heseltine, I think) on the question of forced airdrops in Burma. Doing that would kill off whatever chance there currently is the generals allowing all the aid agencies in… today I am beginning to change my mind; it looks increasingly like they aren’t going to allow anyone in. Perhaps assertive humanitarianism is now the least worst option.

  • Dominic, I thought that the “as a Johnson” line was part of the long-term project to get us all to think that BoJo is a great optimistic Reagan figure who, in years to come, we will turn to in gloomy times and elect into Number 10.

  • Passing Tory 24th May '08 - 10:51pm

    Sorry for the delay; been off in a corner of the world with no internet.

    Sesenco, you have not presented a coherant set of facts; you have repeated one fact again and again.

    Tempted as I am to go through the details of my position I am afraid I will have to decline. There comes a point where revealing data to other parties is just a little rude. As for the final conclusion, you can take it or leave it; it is no problem to me … if you really want to believe that Cameron is in a terrible hole and only releasing huge swathes of policy will get him out of it, and that all is well in Lib Dem land, then who am I to shatter your dreams?

    However, I would have thought that the C&N result should have been a prompt for you to reconsider at least a little.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User Avatarchris moore 18th Feb - 3:26pm
    Good post, Lorenzo. Your warm optimism and benevolence has induced me to look on this development more positively. I still believe it'll be all uphill...
  • User AvatarDavid raw 18th Feb - 3:26pm
    Get ready for at least ten more years of Tory government - despite Brexit and the latest Honda news. None of them at the same...
  • User AvatarLorenzo Cherin 18th Feb - 3:12pm
    These are seven individuals. Amongst them are people I greatly like and definitely admire. Amongst them are one or two not as familiar to me...
  • User Avatarmarcstevens 18th Feb - 3:12pm
    She seems quite happy in Syria giving media interviews and the ideology she subscribes to iwould destroy democracy and get rid of equal rights so...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 18th Feb - 3:04pm
    There will be a parliamentary bye-election soon because of the death of Labour MP Paul Flynn (84). The Independent seven will need to decide whether...
  • User AvatarGlenn 18th Feb - 2:38pm
    My attitude to said young Mum is that she is a British Citizen and has a right to return. but deserves little sympathy. Please tell...