Brown double-counts Iraq troop withdrawal figures

So, Gordon Brown proudly announces that 1,000 troops are to be withdrawn from Iraq.

The BBC headlines the story “UK troops in Basra cut by 1,000”.

Job done? Well, one small problem. You see, Brown might say “1,000” and the BBC might report “1,000” but you know what? 500 of those troops were already coming home anyway. So it’d more be a matter of “Brown announces withdrawal of 500 troops and then adds in 500 more in the hope that no-one would remember that was already happening anyway”.

As Ming Campbell says:

“Any troop withdrawal from Iraq is welcome, but this is a cynical effort to manipulate the figures.”

Remind me. What happened to all that leaving spin behind stuff?

UPDATE: Oh dear. This turned out to just be a brief and incomplete summary of the full sorry mess which turned 2,000 into zero.

Read more by .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Geoffrey Payne 2nd Oct '07 - 6:56pm

    Of course the reason given is that our troops are “handing over” control to the “Iraqi forces”. Does anyone imagine they are not already infiltrated by insurgents? Does anyone really think that the regions “handed over” are now relatively safe and secure? If they were, the journalists will go there and say so, maybe even Brown could do that. But he won’t because it is too dangerous to go there.
    In truth Iraq today is a no-win situation. Whether are troops stay or leave we are dammed, but we still have to make a choice. What is going on is nothing less than propaganda. The occupying forces in Iraq are defeated and there is nothing anyone can do about it. All the occupying troops should leave. Iraq will turn into chaos, but that is what it is in most regions today anyway.
    In the meantime our troops stay, putting their lives at risk in order to prevent Gordan Brown from looking stupid under the pretence that they are “finishing a job”. A high price to pay for a politician’s vanity.

  • Geoffrey Payne 2nd Oct '07 - 6:58pm

    That should read
    “whether our troops stay or leave …”

    Sorry about that, cannot edit comments.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Chris Moore
    @Paul: the Oxford result isn't a Green gain. A Green councillor resigned to cause the by-election. (S/he was first elected in 2022.) It's a three member ward...
  • David Raw
    Argyll & Bute had successive Liberal/Lib Dem MPs for twenty eight years as recently as between 1987 and 2015....
  • David Le Grice
    TBF that first Newham result actually is impressive since the greens have recently come ahead of us by default in urban areas and Newham isn't even one of those...
  • Paul Barker
    That Oxford result is a Green gain, from Labour....
  • Ruth Bright
    Just to elaborate...In the last few minutes of the morning session Swinson explains how she was pushing and pushing to see the Second Sight report. The enquiry ...