Why Holborn and St Pancras deserves our all

It is no secret that Liberal Democrats have become one of the first and foremost Parties in Local Government, having consistently made gains for the last seven years of Local Elections and this strategy was successful in giving us 72 MPs in 2024. But one place where we have suffered a great absence of success has been in Parliamentary by-elections, where we haven’t made a gain since 2023. This is obviously bad for a few reasons, by-elections often indicate loudly and clearly to the public who has momentum, and seeing a major victory can translate into added strength, for example, before Gorton & Denton, YouGov (who predicted the 2024 General Election roughly correct) had the Greens polling at 17%, after Hannah Spencer won, they were up to 21%. It is not as if this secret of success is somehow foreign to us either, in the early 1980s we adeptly used by-elections to challenge the Party system when Bill Pitt, Shirley Williams and Roy Jenkins won startling victories in areas (like Gorton & Denton) that would’ve been considered safe seats, driving up polling for the Alliance to a leading position by early 1982.

Of course, what has become the classic response line among Liberal Democrats to this reality is that, “under our present electoral system Seats matter more than polls.” While this is true to an extent, it is often forgotten that the polls directly affect our ability to expand; for example in 2010 when we won 23% of the vote, we came second place in 243 Seats, whereas in 2024, when we won only 12% of the vote we came second in only 27. Given we are now polling as low as 8%you may judge for yourself how that will affect us.

In this context Starmer’s resignation as an MP, in what has been dubbed his “Last U-Turn” after promising to stay on until the next General Election has presented Liberal Democrats with a golden opportunity, it is unlikely that Reform or the Conservatives will do well here and given it is the Seat of a former Prime Minister it is all the more notable of a by-election. The challenge of course being that it is a Labour safe seat, and the fact Zack Polanski is running. We should make no bones about the fact Polanski’s leadership as leader of the Green Party is a threat to our position as the progressive alternative to Labour, in the last set of locals the Greens made gains in areas that once would’ve been strong for us such as in Manchester, even if we don’t win, denying him a victory will benefit us, as it will halt his already slowing momentum and any Labour candidate will have to weather the struggle of incumbency anyway.

It is in this respect that our success in becoming a Party of local Government may aid us, we need to make it clear to voters that we are not simply a tactical choice, but the practical choice. There is much a point to be made about our success with the four-day work week, which Labour opposed, or our success in pushing for expanded housebuilding programmes, which the Greens opposed – and both of these are in Cambridgeshire alone. Additionally there is a narrative we can form about those disillusioned with failed Prime Ministers seeing a brighter future in us given we already hold Theresa May’s former Seat. The opportunity is here, we just need to grab it

If you’re near the area and/or have some spare time I would highly recommend getting in contact with the Camden Liberal Democrats and asking what you can do to help out. If we want to win over 100 Seats at the next General Election, or even break Asquith’s record, we need to make it clear to Britain that Liberals have not just the policy, but the momentum to be in power next time.

* Rosemary Runswick is a Liberal Democrat activist in West Suffolk and a member of the Radical Association. She writes a blog at the Green Ribbon Club (https://greenribbonclub.blogspot.com/p/about.html).

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

5 Comments

  • Tristan Ward 5th Sep '26 - 3:42pm

    Totally agree.

    A campaign that emphasises closeness to Europe, strong defence now the US is unreliable, growth and actually doing something about climate change s what I would like to see.

    There is even a Gail’s in the Brunswick Centre.

  • Nonconformistradical 5th Sep '26 - 4:38pm

    As far as I can see from

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holborn_and_St_Pancras

    https://tinyurl.com/mtym5knx

    and https://tinyurl.com/4vwct8wh

    The constituency is within the London Borough of Camden, on which we have ten councillors – but all are in the north-west of the borough, not in the Holborn_and_St_Pancras constituency and our election track record in the constituency is not great after 2010.

    Not saying we should not put resources into this by-election – it has too high a profile not to be treated seriously.

    But let’s have some serious and achievable objectives please.

  • Mick Taylor 5th Sep '26 - 4:39pm

    Totally agree as well. This is a chance to test out our anti Labour messages and try out new techniques to see if we can wrest votes from both Labour and the Greens. Tristan has identified 3 lines of attack, I would add voting reform and campaigning for small businesses and cooperatives.
    I was pleased to see at least one of our MPs has already been door knocking in H&SP. All our MPs should be offering their services as well as London assembly members and councillors all over London. Let’s give this our best shot.

  • paul barker 5th Sep '26 - 5:39pm

    What Our Party deserves in this By-election is some hard thinking first of all. Can we make an intervention that would attract some National Publicity ?
    The only thing I can suggest is if We campaign on one or two issues that make The Right-Wing Media so angry that they forget to ignore Us.

    If people are thinking that We might win or come 2nd ( or 3rd, 4th or 5th) then they are fooling themselves. This By-election will be a Two-Horse Race between Labour & The Greens with a Secondary race for 3rd place between Reform & The Conservatives; everyone else will be squeezed “till the pips squeak”.

  • Peter Davies 5th Sep '26 - 6:10pm

    “The only thing I can suggest is if We campaign on one or two issues that make The Right-Wing Media so angry that they forget to ignore Us.” – and that includes social media. Europe certainly fits that criterion. Climate change is also something we should be more strident on than the Greens. Many Green activists and presumably voters are noticing that Polanski has shifted the party’s focus away from green issues.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Davies
    "The only thing I can suggest is if We campaign on one or two issues that make The Right-Wing Media so angry that they forget to ignore Us." - and that includes...
  • paul barker
    What Our Party deserves in this By-election is some hard thinking first of all. Can we make an intervention that would attract some National Publicity ? The o...
  • Mick Taylor
    Totally agree as well. This is a chance to test out our anti Labour messages and try out new techniques to see if we can wrest votes from both Labour and the Gr...
  • Nonconformistradical
    As far as I can see from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holborn_and_St_Pancras https://tinyurl.com/mtym5knx and https://tinyurl.com/4vwct8wh The c...
  • Tristan Ward
    Totally agree. A campaign that emphasises closeness to Europe, strong defence now the US is unreliable, growth and actually doing something about climate c...