Chuka on Question Time – open thread

Chuka Umunna is about to be on Question Time.

I should be going to bed, but I can’t resist staying up and watching.

Who’s with me?Chuka’s first intervention came to the first question, about the Labour manifesto. He talked about how Brexit would make it impossible for Labour to implement what it promised – especially as it would be tougher for people to come here to build the houses it said it wants.


A woman in the audience tried to make out it would be fine – but surely people in EU countries will head for other EU countries and ignore us – especially if we are going to extend the hostile environment to them.

Well this is getting a bit animated.

The second question was about the dreadful incident during the leaders’ debate when Conservative head office press account Twitter pretended to be a fact checking organisation.

This led to a brilliant intervention by a woman wearing a niqab. She talked about how she had a degree in English and was a teacher and how horrendous it was to have the Prime Minister talk about women like her in horrendously racist terms.

Tory minister Robert Jenrick tried to dismiss this and Chuka just went for him – “you can’t seriously be defending this.” he said.

The most amusing thing was Shadow Justice Secretary Richard Burgon showcase his talent for digging while in a hole. He was the one who famously talked about how the polls showed Labour losing in 2017 – for Kay Burley to point out that Labour did in fact lose. The example he gave tonight about politicians misleading politicians was about the dodgy dossier.

The third question was about whether the Royal Family needed to be re-evaluated in the light of the scandal engulfing Prince Andrew. Chuka said that we don’t need to change the institution but talked about Prince Andrew’s behaviour as being disgraceful and how unfathomable it was for him to have gone and stayed with Epstein after his conviction.

The last question was about fire safety in the wake of Grenfell and the fire in Bolton at the weekend. Chuka slammed the lack of action by the government, citing a Conservative housing minister who refused to order the cladding in the Bolton fire to be removed.

For once Question Time was actually watchable. Chuka seems very much at home as a Liberal Democrat.


* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Caron Lindsay Caron Lindsay 21st Nov '19 - 11:48pm

    @Ruth – I’m going to bed…..

  • Brexitcast is over-rated. I actually quite like all of them individually as reporters, so it should be good, but the unfunny in-jokes and constant talking over each other make it hard to watch.
    Chuka was OK tonight, but my main take-away from QT was what a nasty person Richard Burgon seems to be. I’ve never rated him as a politician, but he just seemed nasty tonight. Not a good look.

  • John Marriott 22nd Nov '19 - 9:02am

    And what about the look on Burgos’s face when he realised that the quite ordinary guy in the audience was earning over £80,000 a year? Talking of ‘Burgon bingo’, try counting up the number of times that Barry Gardiner or Rebecca Long-Bailey use the phrase ‘let me make it perfectly clear’. As for going to bed. I tend to watch Newsnight live, while recording Question Time and watch it over an early copper the following morning.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

This post has pre moderation enabled, please be patient whilst waiting for it to be manually reviewed. Liberal Democrat Voice is made up of volunteers who keep the site running in their free time.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Mick Taylor
    MMT - and by the way, I didn't mean to be taken seriously about Ed's conversion to MMT, I am certain he hasn't - argues clearly that taxation follows spending r...
  • Nick Baird
    @Laurence Cox - I disagree regarding equalising capital gains tax rates with income tax. A taxable capital gain is usually a reward for accepting a certain amou...
  • Roland
    There are many levels to this, one of which is around expectations and “status”. I get the impression that Alan feels returning to live with his parents is ...
  • Roland
    @martin - I think we are violently agreeing, my point was not to provide a “definition” but to illustrate the words carried differing baggage and thus valid...
  • Roland
    More detail needed. My cousin had an operation cancelled several times over the last two years. Once because the implant manufacturer announced a vastly upgr...