Danny Alexander and Alison McInnes challenge SNP on armed police in Scotland

Police motorbike - Some rights reserved by Metropolitan PoliceI’ve written several times recently about how policing has changed in Scotland since Scotland’s eight police forces were merged into one.  Concerns have been expressed on a number of issues:

While Danny Alexander complained last week about the use of armed and mounted police in the highlands, it now appears that armed police are being routinely deployed across Scotland without the safeguard of a senior officer granting permission for each use.

I’ve said before that Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has the clearest desk in the Scottish Government’s HQ as he seems to think that everything is an operational matter for the Police. Willie Rennie was wrong when he said that the Police merger would create two very powerful people – one of them seems to just abrogate all responsibility. In this case, it’s clear he’s just given the police a free rein to fundamentally change the nature of policing on Scotland’s streets. Armed Police across Scotland now have a standing authority to carry weapons even when they’re doing routine things like overseeing closing time in pubs on Friday and Saturday nights or going to traffic incidents. Before, the arms would have been locked away and authority granted by a senior officer for their use on a case by case basis.

This change has been made without any parliamentary scrutiny or debate. Yes, that’s right. The Parliament, its Justice Committee, its Policing Sub-Committee were completely kept in the dark about this for over a year. What way is that to run a government?

My view is that this anytime, anyplace, anywhere approach to deadly weapons is disproportionate, illiberal and irresponsible. I’m not alone in that view. Yesterday’s Inverness Courier leader said:

This uniformity of approach from the “Wild West” of Scotland to our much less rumbustious city is not what the public wants.”

Alison McInnes questioned MacAskill on the matter yesterday:

Get Adobe Flash player

Afterwards, she said:

It is deeply concerning that neither the Justice Secretary or Police Scotland saw any need to tell anyone that firearms officers are  carrying guns while undertaking everyday duties and no longer need the authorisation of senior officers to fire them.

There is no hiding the fact that this is a significant change from a strict regime of only carrying firearms while responding to a clear threat to public safety, approved on a case-by-case basis and following a proper risk assessment.

The removal of this important safeguard and adoption of a blanket policy of approval to carry and use guns has been implemented by stealth. It appears that both Parliament and the SPA were in the dark about it for over a year.

With the Justice Secretary content to give the Chief Constable a free rein, despite the concerns of members of all parties, it is clear that the Parliament is going to have to do all it can to get a grip on this situation.

“We don’t want that sort of thing here”

This is what Danny Alexander had to say about armed police routinely patrolling in his constituency. His comments were reminiscent of those of Clarence Henry Willcock, the last person to be prosecuted for failing to show an identity card, who said “I’m a liberal and I’m against that sort of thing.”

Again, Scottish Liberal Democrats are showing their worth, standing up against the illiberal, authoritarian approach of the SNP towards freedom and justice. Kenny MacAskill is well past his sell-by date as Justice Secretary. It’s surely time for him to be replaced with someone who actually gives a damn about civil liberties. If someone can so radically change the relationship between police and citizen without a second thought, surely they are not fit for office.

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Joe Bourke
    It is an interesting article, John. The Biden administration will surely have an important role to play but perhaps of more relevance may be Israel's rapproachm...
  • Peter Hirst
    China and Russia have strategic interests and they must sometimes overlap. China seems more emenable to western values despite its lack of democracy. They will ...
  • David Evans
    The deal was signed by Boris Johnson and the Conservatives because they were under duress - the duress of an absurd promise to "get Brexit done" without anyone ...
  • David Evans
    It is sad to see that the centrists have been outmanoeuvred by the right once again. When the leader of the fourth largest party becomes PM for the first two ...
  • William Francis
    @Roland. Building new railways is if anything anti-1960s thinking. That was the era of mass motorway expansion and the Beeching cuts. This country's continua...