Jacqui Smith: our very own Donald Rumsfeld

You know, I think the Home Secretary Jacqui Smith is turning into our very own Donald Rumsfeld.

After the previous entertainments caused by her rather odd pair of views (here and here) on walking and the little problem over the timing of her kebab purchases, we had this morning something right up there in the Mr Rumsfeld class.

On being challenged on the Today program that she was wanting to introduce detention without charge for 42 days only in order to cover hypothetical situations (rather than to deal with any current problem), she retorted:

It won’t be hypothetical if and when it occurs. We are not legislating now on the basis that we are bringing it in now for something that might happen in the future; we are bringing it in now for something that might happen in the future; we are bringing in a position for if it becomes unhypothetical. If, unfortunately I and many other experts are right and we do need it in the future it is in place. (Transcript courtesy of Benedict Brogan)

As Paul Walter points out:

You could say that about any hypothetical situation, for example:

Minister: We have to legislate in case the Earth turns into cheese.

Interviewer: But that’s a hypothetical situation.

Minister: But it won’t be hypothetical if and when it happens.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in News.


  • That is a hilarious quote. I think someone ought to go around to the home office with a dictionary and explain the meaning of hypothetical to her

  • LiberalHammer 24th Jan '08 - 4:19pm

    What a feeble argument! It could be used to justify absolutely anything. And any piece of legislation no matter how insane

  • Things can only get better.... 24th Jan '08 - 6:10pm

    This is definitely a candidate for one of those ‘Foot in Mouth’ awards…

  • Dennis the Menace... 26th Jan '08 - 6:08pm

    Truly surreal…

    Politicians are normally trained NEVER to comment on any hypothetical situations, so for our Jax to make it a policy strategy does rather beggar belief…

    Still, I’m sure she knows what she’s doing..

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Martin Gray
    Ultimately - you cannot sustain the current levels of immigration, & solve the housing crisis simultaneously...Sadly too many progressives are infatuated wi...
  • Nonconformistradical
    "Blaming them for promising amenities (to get planning permission) that they then find endless excuses to delay, however…" A key issue and the one which resu...
  • Joe Bourke
    The Renew Europe demand that the EU Council and Commission take responsibility and finally take further steps to apply Article 7, which could lead to the remova...
  • Cassie
    @Simon R – “I don’t think we can blame developers for building the houses they think they can most easily sell for a profit.” I, for one, wasn't blamin...
  • Joe Bourke
    Vernon Bogdanor has an interesting analysis of the rise of the Reform party in contrast with the SDP of the 1980s https://inews.co.uk/opinion/reform-no-fimmick-...