John Stuart Mill has, perhaps inevitably, been acclaimed the ‘greatest British liberal of all time’, according to a poll conducted by the Liberal Democrat History Group. (Hat-tip: Jonathan Calder via Paul Walter).
Duncan Brack, editor of the Journal of Liberal History, wrote about the contest last week on Lib Dem Voice, including brief profiles of the four short-listed candidates, who also included Gladstone, Keynes and Lloyd George. (Only the deceased were eligible.)
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
We need a healthy and free leadership debate (Rosemary Runswick)
Mathew on Monday: Davey has been given a second chance. Now he must show us what his leadership is for (Mathew Hulbert)
The decapitation strategy (Michael Taylor)
Welcome (belatedly) to my day: 12 October 2026 – a leadership challenge, or a challenge to the leadership?… (Mark Valladares)
Is Ed Davey toast? (Caron Lindsay)
"A little heaven here on earth": Launde Abbey in Leicestershire
Paul Simon: That's Why God Made the Movies
The Joy of Six 1591
MI5 chief confirms Russian interference in Brexit referendum
The abandoned platforms of South Kensington
The only Tory MP to gain a seat at the last election is under threat
'They were casting out demons': Scottish manager recalls attending exorcism with Gordon Brown to sign a player
How many councillors has Reform UK lost since the May 2026 elections?
IFS warn on the budget
Ying Perrett 
Graham Evans 
Tim Rogers 
paul barker 
Rose Runswick 
2 Comments
It is said that in later years Mill doubted liberalism and eventually turned his back to it. I think that I have even seen some quotes from him which seemed to prove this, but I can’t remember enough that I could refind them. Does anybody else have a clue?
Anyway, I still think that the greatest liberal was John Locke. He laid the ground for all liberals who came later, including Mill.
I don’t think it was at all inevitable! As someone who voted for Lloyd G, with Gladstone a very close second, I am very disappointed! 🙂
The speaker at the meeting on Wednesday night for Mill, Richard Reeves, was simply brilliant. He spoke exceptionally well, and I also learnt a lot about Mill, especially his non-intellectual political activities, and will probably even buy his forthcoming biography of him. But I still don’t think he was the greatest Liberal!